This agent has 23 reviews.


Misty , a seller from Smyrna, DE
Peggy always gets the job done ! Thank you Peggy!
2023
Not Peggys Client, thank God., a buyer from Milford, DE
Luckily, we did not choose Peggy as our personal realtor, but we did have to work with her as she was the selling agent of the home we bought. Throughout the process Peggy was extremely unprofessional. We had to threaten to sue her and her client in order to get a septic inspection, which is Delaware State Law. She thought selling a property as is means no septic inspection, incorrect. Not only is it state law, it was included in the contract, which they signed. She also provided the wrong name for the contract. It was inherited after a death and obvious to most, a deceased person cannot sign any paperwork. Most infuriating of all her mess ups is that her and the seller left the house fully furnished which was noticed during the walk through and would not compensate for a dumpster nor moving fees. This breached the contract as well, selling a house as is does not mean leaving your unwanted belongings. The contract clearly stated the expectations. Unfortunately we did not have time to sue them for this as we were expecting to sign that same day. Friends, please do not use Peggy as your realtor. She made our first time home buying experience complicated and drawn out. Not happy with her nor compass reality.
2023
M. Horvath, a buyer from Norristown, PA
Peggy is a fantastic person, to just say realtor would be selling her short. She's so much more than that.

She is extremely knowledgeable and a wonderful advocate for anyone just getting into buying or selling their home.

She takes the time to cross all the t's and dot the i's, while making sure each client understands all the fine print.

She is a wonderful person to have on your team, and I would recommend her to anyone looking for a great experience.


2023
Amanda, a buyer from Millsboro, DE
Peggy was AMAZING! This was our second home and I learned so much about the home buying process compared to the first time. She takes her time to teach, explain the forms, and even have a friendly chat when feeling stressed out. She double checks every detail on homes and even contracts that are submitted protecting us and our money. Including getting us the maximum amount back and the sale of our home! She truly goes the extra mile for her clients first. It was a pleasure sharing this experience and many laughs along the way.

2022
buyer, a buyer from Lewes, DE
I had a horrible experience with her. Just downright RUDE and unprofessional. Very abrupt and brash in her mannerisms. Non-responsive. Will never do business with her again. She was quick to pass judgement. She's a bull in a china shop. Being at the table with her was frankly embarrassing.
2022
John C, a buyer from Magnolia, DE
Huge appreciation for Peggy Sue (& associates) for representing us, looking out for our interests, and fighting for our wishes through the last year and a half!

My wife and I began the long road of building a custom home during a pandemic back in late Spring of 2020. At that time, after looking at a couple options, we decided on a particular custom home builder, so we placed our current house on the market (with Peggy as our Realtor of course!) As many of you reading this know, the house sold in no time. So shortly thereafter, we went under contract for what we believed was going to be the most exciting 6 months--

--Which actually turned out to be a grueling nearly 15 months! From the beginning though, we had Peggy Sue as our agent, and she went above and beyond time and time again to ensure we ended up with the home we were looking forward to. From permit delays to "miscommunications" between us and the builder, from contract missteps to corners attempting to be cut... Peggy was oftentimes more on top of what was actually going on with our house project than the project manager themself! Then, when it finally came down to the week of settlement, she was still fighting to save us every dollar she could right up to the day of closing.

Peggy Sue Mitchell means what she says when she tells you she has your best interests at heart. She isn't just your agent; she partners with you and your family to secure your house-shaped dreams.

Thanks again, Peggy, for everything!
2021
Karen, a buyer from Wilmington, DE
Peggy is such a professional. She knows real estate. I was so impressed with her knowledge and ideas. Did the best job ever!!!!
2021
sherrie, a buyer from Harrington, DE
I highly recommend Peggy Sue Cales Mitchell. Peggy helped my boyfriend and I purchase our first home. I really liked that Peggy listened to what I wanted in a home and my boyfriend both. I liked that Peggy found us a home that had everything on our list. I appreciated Peggy from our first phone call to our first meeting. Peggy came to my home and sat down with my boyfriend and I and went over entire home buying process with us. I appreciate that she also made the home buying process fun instead of being like a chore. We had some great laughs and fun during our home searching with Peggy. I also consider myself little high strung and she always seem to calm me down and answer any concerns I had. Home buying can be stressful but she manage to always talk me off the ledge at times. Peggy is a real hoot and great personality. I enjoyed just being around her. Peggy is about her clients and will go out to bat for you and has your back. Peggy doesn't treat you like your just a paycheck. Peggy truly cares about her clients interest. Peggy was there every step of the way. I will defiantly use Peggy as my realtor on any future purchase. I appreciate Peggy mostly because even after you settle on your home she is still there for you. Peggy will still answer her phone and help where she can and still get answers for you. Peggy Sue Cales Mitchell is truly a gem.
2021
Erin, a buyer from Middletown, DE
We recently had the privilege of purchasing our second home with Peggy Sue and it was nothing other than exceptional. Peggy Sue went above and beyond to help my family and I find the perfect home in an extremely challenging real estate market. She was highly organized, exceptional in communication and notably knowledgeable making, not only the searching process but also the buying process easy and stress free. She walked alongside us through each and every step of the process and was truly out for our best interest. We would highly recommend Peggy Sue as she is a real estate agent who truly stands out apart from the rest.
2021
Stacey, a buyer from Newark, DE
Peggy Sue is the best! So knowledgeable, encouraging and patient! In this tough market and multiple offers not accepted she never gave up. She knew we would find the house meant for us! And she did! We are so happy in our new home!
2021
Jason, a buyer from New Castle, DE
I was referred to Peggy by a friend and it was an excellent decision. From my first call to closing, she was phenomenal. She was ALWAYS available to answer my questions often answering texts within 10 minutes. She was ALWAYS honest with me about the good and the bad. She offered solutions and provided multiple options for every issue that occurred. When touring houses she offered honest feedback based on her long history in the business. As a first time home buyer, I found this to be invaluable during the long process. I've already recommended Peggy to a few friends and will continue to do so.
2021
Steve, a seller from Magnolia, DE
We are now enjoying our new home, which is a perfect fit for my wife Katie and I. We had hoped and planned for a home for quite some time, and it just became a reality. We are so pleased, with the home and the experience, but we did not do it on our own.
We would like to express our thanks and much gratitude to Peggy Sue Mitchell. Her knowledge of the market, professionalism, and energy are unmatched. But her dedication to our interest and needs are one of the many attributes that sets Peggy Sue apart from the rest, making her the best!
Peggy Sue worked with us long before we were ready to search for a home, by preparing us, so that we would be considered serious buyers and financially capable to make an offer with confidence.
Her efforts did not stop after we had gone into contract, but she kicked it up a notch, plotting out every step leading up to and through closing. Lots of lists and reminders! We were able to relax throughout the entire process. No drama.
Lets do it again, Peggy! Thank you.

2020
Heather, a seller from Wilmington, DE
We started our home sale journey with Peggy Sue Mitchell in June 2019. From the onset of our relationship with her she was an invaluable source of information and solid advice. Peggy Sue consistently responded in a friendly, professional and timely manner and was always mindful to make efficient use of our time. Her attention to details and level of service was beyond compare. When we voiced concern about COVID-19 delaying the sale listing, she quelled our fears and assured us that the market was still hot. She assisted us to get our house on the market two days earlier than projected and helped us garner eight offers, all of which were over asking price. She represented us at settlement so we could relocate and move on with our lives. I would highly recommend Peggy Sue to family, friends, and strangers for all of their real estate needs.
2020
Schippt55, a seller from Wilmington, DE
As the buying and selling of a home is one of the most daunting processes that is a part of life, I wanted to share our recent experience. It turned out that selling our home has been excellent in no small part due to Berkshire Hathaway and our agent, Peggy Sue Mitchell. Having worked in the hotel and hospitality industry for over 40 years, we relish feedback from our guests/customers and treat it as a gift.

Peggys assistance has been invaluable to us. Her knowledge, guidance, professionalism and patience made her a valued partner in this process. Berkshire Hathaway agency is fortunate to have her on their team.

The preparation for the listing was spot on and the listing itself excellent. This was evident by the interest from day one when it was listed as Coming Soon and the number of showings scheduled once it was listed as For Sale (41 before we cut them off). Her guidance in prepping the home proved to be equally on the mark as we received 8 offers within 3 days. During the review of the offers, she provided explanation and an analysis of each offer which allowed us to make an informed decision. Although, we have yet to finish the process (closing), I have no doubt it will go smoothly.

Although, we did not have any friends or neighbors looking for a realtor at this time, we would not hesitate to recommend the Berkshire Hathaway agency and especially Peggy.

Thanks again to Peggy and the team at Berkshire Hathaway for all of their help.
2020
K.Baker, a seller from Newark, DE
Ahh man Peggy Sue is a purely genuine and beautiful person inside and out. My husband and I have had the pleasure of knowing Peggy since May 2019. She's been with us every step of the way in guiding us to our dream home. Peggy gave good advice to us when we first spoke to help my husband and I work on our credit score. Being a first time home buyer is exciting but the process is nail biting, to have someone like Peggy makes the experience something that you wont forgot! She's dedicated and you can tell how passionate she is to help. If you ever get a chance to work with this "ray of sunshine" and get to witness that unique but contagious laugh of hers I promise you won't regret it. Appreciate you much Peggy!
2020
Travis Vogl, a seller from Smyrna, DE
Peggy was a pleasure to work with and she was always available for a quick call when needed. I truly felt as though Peggy was just as invested in my home purchase and happiness with the transaction as I was.
2020
Rodney and Pam, a seller from Hartly, DE
It was a true pleasure working with Peggy Sue Mitchell. She went above and beyond to help us move through the selling process smoothly and to be prepared for each step.
2019
naenae418, a buyer from Claymont, DE
My husband and I had the opportunity to work with Peggy Sue Mitchell in our search for a new home. We were nervous, but Peggy was a wonderful agent, VERY patient, had a good sense of humor, kept us laughing and helped us through the whole process. Peggy was such a blessing to us and we are in our new home, I still call Peggy as I consider her not just an agent, but a friend. The process is over but Peggy will always remain in hearts and her phone number in our cell phones. If you are looking for a good, honest, cool agent with LOTS of experience and knowledge, that would be Peggy Sue Mitchell. Peggy, thank you so much for everything your did for us, We can't thank you enough! You made the process so easy.

Renee and Derrick W.

2019
Donna , a buyer from Smyrna, DE
I met Peggy Sue Mitchell looking at a property. Upon first meeting I could tell she was professional . She makes the process of buying a home easy and effortless. She is knowledgeable, experienced, and diligent. She is always available anytime of day to answer my questions, research and answer, or schedule a showing, I have dealt with many real estate agents and I have not seen more dedication or drive. She is definitely a different breed!
2019
Bob and Nigina, a buyer from Wilmington, DE
Peggy Sue is a true professional. She was always prepared for all listings that we were viewing even the ones on short notice. She negotiated seven different offers for us until finally we were successful in purchasing our first home. She even went above and beyond our expectations by negotiating with the former owner (house flipper) when the hvac unit was broken during our final walk through and the electric was rewired incorrectly between our house inspection and final closing. Peggy Sue saved us thousands by constantly following up with the former owner until they fixed the issues and did so before we had to pursue legal means. It was truly a pleasure working with Peggy Sue and we would highly recommend her to anyone blooking to purchase a new home.
2018
Laurie, a seller from Harrington, DE
I moved out of state 2 years ago and was struggling to sell my home when my sister introduced me to Peggy Sue, she was AMAZING she stepped right in and within days had an offer on my home she did everything for me and I never had to come back to Del she dealt with the clients, bank and the lawyers and after a few months the house was Sold I really thought I was going to loose the house in foreclosure she really saved me. Thank you so much Peggy you are an awesome person and realtor.
2018
Metalfabman, a seller from CAMDEN WYOMING, DE
Peggy Sue Mitchell was an unbelievable asset during the entire staging, list and selling process! Her attention to detail and responsiveness during the sale of my farm was unmatched, considering the type of property she was tasked with selling. nIt is not everyday you have an 11 acre farm that has as many options to pursue that my property had. She pursued all options and all avenues to draw as many buyers as she possibly could, to view the property at every showing!!! A true pleasure to work with, down to closing day. I would highly recommend Peggy Sue Mitchell for all of your Real Estate needs! Top Shelf!
2017
Jessica, a buyer from Wyoming, DE
Working with Peggy made buying a home a breeze. From start to finish, she knew what we needed and openly showed us all our options. She's always available (literally) and happy to help with any question you may have - being first time home buyers meant we had a lot of questions. Her constant patience and kindness was so appreciated. She even helped recommend a lender who made the loan process much easier. We never had to worry if anything would be overlooked. Right down to the closing table, Peggy had every detail in order and we couldn't be happier. Look no further for a Realtor, Peggy is a helpful and knowledgeable expert who will soon become part of your family.
2017