James Thompson, Watkinsville, Georgia, a seller from Youngstown, OH
I worked with Tibitha Matheney following my mother's passing in Boardman, Ohio to help sell her condominium. I live out of state in Georgia so I expected this to be quite challenging; however, with Tibitha's help the sale of the condo was smooth and easy. She is extremely knowledgeable regarding local contacts you may need such as title agents and handyman services. Her knowledge of the local housing market was vast, and she researched well. Our property had an offer we approved within 24 hours of being listed! I highly recommend Tibitha for all your realtor needs.
I worked with Tibitha following my mother's passing in Boardman, Ohio to help sell her condominium. I live out of state in Georgia, so I expected this to be quite challenging; however, with Tibitha's help the sale of the condo was smooth and easy. She is extremely knowledgeable regarding local contacts you may need such as title agents and handyman services. Her knowledge of the local housing market was vast, and she researched well. Our property had an offer we approved within 24 hours of being listed! I highly recommend Tibitha for all your realtor needs. 2024
Jared M, Boardman, Ohio, a buyer from Youngstown, OH
Tibitha was helpful navigating the home buying process. She was there for us every step of the way and made the process as smooth as possible! We would highly recommend Tibitha for all of your home buying and/or selling needs!
Jenny C., Boardman, OH, a seller from Youngstown, OH
I couldn't be happier with Tibitha! She has made this whole process wonderful. Her knowledge & attentiveness to detail was so comforting. I will definitely recommend her to friends and family in the future.
If I had to do this all again, Id choose Tibitha time and again. She was attentive, knowledgeable and so kind through this whole process. We will be recommending her to anyone we know who may need realty services in our area. 2024
Robert and Kimberly jackson, Canfield, a seller from Salem, OH
If you like results you'll love Tibitha! Problem here problem there, solution made every time. She knows a lot about a lot of things and gives great opinions and advice. She's honest and pokes you in the eye when needed. She accepted my law enforcement and military background with open arms. So I suggest veterans to give her a call. She's also knowledgeable on the buyer side and knowing about plans and programs. She knows if you can't find a loan she can't sell you a property, she'll get it done! Results is what she gave me quickly and suggested a great closing company that I appreciated. Thank you for all the hard work. Robert j Jackson jr and Kimberly Jackson
My family used her expertise in helping buy and sell multiple properties over the past few years. Always a pleasure to work with! We refer her to everyone.
This is the second time that I have worked with Tibitha. She was great both times. She has assisted me with both buying and selling a property. She is knowledgeable and on her game. I recommend her 100%. 2024
Amber, Austintown, Ohio, a buyer from Youngstown, OH
Tibitha is a real gem to work with. She listened to my wants and worked with me all the way toward finding my "home". She answered all my questions and was extremely knowledgeable and helpful thru the entire process. I would recommend her to all my family and friends!! Thank you Tibi!!
know her personly-------------she does a fine job....
well done!
Bob Wolfcale - Oxford, MI, a seller from Youngstown, OH
Tibitha is a great asset to have on your team when selling your home. She is friendly, passionate, and a good communicator. She is knowledgeable and kept us informed during the entire process. We sold our home in less than 5 weeks from listing to closing. She went above and beyond to assemble and close the sale. Also, thank you to the team at C21, Nicole and Val, for their outstanding support!
Tibitha is a great asset to have on your team when selling your home. She is friendly, passionate, and a good communicator. She is knowledgeable and kept us informed during the entire process. We sold our home in less than 5 weeks from listing to closing. She went above and beyond to assemble and close the sale. Also, thank you to the team at C21, Nicole and Val, for their outstanding support! 2023
Tibitha was absolutely brilliant! I would recommend her to work with anyone especially someone new looking for a home! She helped me go through the entire process of buying my first home and was there every step of the way! 2023
Joanne Kusky. Youngstown, Ohio , a seller from Youngstown, OH
Each step of selling our home was done as we were ready and Tibitha gave expert advice. The process of selling to signing our home was complete in a little over 5 weeks
I am happy with the service that Tibitha provided me when I sold my condo. She was professional, courteous, and knowledgeable. She helped me with every step of the process, from staging the property, marketing it online, negotiating with buyers, and closing the deal. She always kept me informed and answered all my questions promptly. She sold my condo in less than a month and got me a great price. I would highly recommend Tibitha to anyone looking for a reliable and experienced realtor. She is the best! 2023
Tibitha helped us successfully sell our home if 60 years in just a little over 6 weeks. Tibitha explained things so well to us and the process went smoothly. We are grateful for her help and recommend her real estate experience to those buying and selling property. 2023
Tibitha did an amazing job helping find a home and was informative on the different homes we looked at. As a first time homeowner, she made the process easy and we felt comfortable going to her as well as asking her questions. She answered every text/call and if she wasnt sure about a question we asked, she immediately found the answer for us. She went above and beyond for us and we are so thankful that she helped us find our first house. 2023
Tibi was knowledgeable and helpful throughout this whole house buying process. She helped us at any time we needed her, and she met us at any time we needed to be at a house. She was available on weekends as well. She made the home buying process go a lot smoother for us in this hard market. Definitely recommend to work with her!! 2023
Tibitha was so awesome to work with. She kept us informed of what was going on all the way through the sale of my Moms condo. I highly recommend Tibitha if you are buying or selling your real estate. 2023
Tib is a hardworking and sacrificing individual who takes the extra time to get to know her clients. She is always willing to go that extra mile to ensure her clients needs are met and her deals get closed! If your looking for someone to take your real estate transaction to the next level, then look no further.
Tibitha is kind, efficient, patient, and great with communication. She always responds in a timely manner and gives clear, consise descriptions of things that people not in the business wouldn't be familiar with. She genuinely loves what she is doing and it makes a world of difference.
Always a great experience working with Tibitha! Whether youre buying or selling, she makes the process easy. Great advertising and visibility! She doesnt delay, and is quick to get the process started. We appreciate her communication and always keeping us in the loop. Thanks again!
Tinitha is great to work with. She helped me when I was looking for a house and when I sold my house. She is knowledgeable and I would highly recommend her to everyone.
We recently just closed on our new home. I'm from the East Coast and was accustomed to the house buying experiences there. I was certain that we would be life long renters but Tibitha was able to help me finally see that home ownership was definitely in our future. She was able to help us narrow down exactly what we were looking for in our future home, showed us prospective houses quickly in this crazy market, shared her 20 years experience with us, and was able to answer all our crazy questions. We will absolutely use her in any future real estate needs and refer her to all friends and family for their home buying and selling needs.
Tibitha was great..she's Def a pro at her job and she makes sure u get what ur looking for. She will go up to bat for u! Very professional. I couldn't of asked for a better realtor. 2023
Love working with Tibitha. Shes a likable, friendly person. She makes you feel like youre the only client shes working with. Very personable, prompt, patient, and quick to find out answers to questions. She is always punctual. We appreciate her honesty and trustworthiness. She makes the whole process as smooth as possible.
Tibi is the best agent you could have for BOTH buying and selling. She is high energy, personable, hard working, and overall just "gets it done". 2023
DeeJenkins,Austintown , a seller from Youngstown, OH
Tibitha did an outstanding job in all phases from getting our duplex to the place it could be sold, working with me from out of state, and getting me more than expected for the sale. She was knowledgeable, professional, honest, and kind. Tibitha also provided me with referrals to other agencies that were required. I would gladly use her again and recommend her to my family and friends.
This is our second time working with Tibi on buying and selling a home. Seeing it from both sides now, I can say Tibi is extremely knowledgeable, professional, and attentive. Partnering with her on selling my home was a great decision and Im happy with how she helped me navigate the whole process from start to finish. Highly recommend! 2023
Tibitha did an outstanding job in all phases from getting our duplex to the place it could be sold, working with me from out of state, and getting me more than expected for the sale. She was knowledgeable, professional, honest, and kind. Tibitha also provided me with referrals to other agencies that were required. I would gladly use her again and recommend her to my family and friends. 2023
Andrew Killian Rocky River , a seller from Youngstown, OH
A friend recommended Tibitha to me because they had a history of dealing with her and were satisfied. She sold my house in record time and was helpful and available to my questions. I recommend Tibitha highly.
Tibitha is the best of the best realtor we have ever worked with. She is professional and knowledgeable, but she is a joy to work with!! 2023
Rick Mistovich, Campbell, a seller from Campbell, OH
We had an excellent experience with Tibitha Matheny. She answered every call, every question and did so in a timely and friendly manner. She understood our goals, shared recommendations based off of her experience which paid off with the rapid sale of our house in the targeted price range. I definitely would work with Tinitha again and have already recommended her to friends.
Steve & Emma - Austintown, a buyer from Youngstown, OH
Tibi is an amazing realtor! She was timely, knowledgeable, and truly understood/met our needs throughout our home buying process. We found the perfect starter home with her help and we couldn't be happier!
If I could give more than 5 stars I would! Tibi was absolutely amazing - made this complicated process a breeze. Couldnt be happier with our first home!! 2023
Tibi had helped immensely throughout the home buying process, and her extensive real estate connections, experience, and prowess proved to have valuable insight during the home buying experience. 2023
Larry Froehlich, Canfield, OH, a seller from Youngstown, OH
I recently completed my second transaction with Tibi and I could not be more pleased. She is VERY knowledge, listens to your questions, makes great suggestions and made both the purchase and selling of my property effortless. Wow, she is great to work with. Thank you Tibi!
Ryan Brooks youngstown, a buyer from Youngstown, OH
Tibitha provided my family and I with the best advice. Any time I had a question she was 99.9% available, always on time to the several homes that my family and I wanted to look at.
I recently completed my second transaction with Tibi and I could not be more pleased. She is VERY knowledge, listens to your questions, makes great suggestions and made both the purchase and selling of my property effortless. Wow, she is great to work with. Thank you Tibi! Larry Froehlich, Canfield, OH 2023
By far the best person ever to buy or get help to buy a home. You are informed about everything before it happens so theres never a surprise. 2023
Bryan Franczkowski, Youngstown OH, a seller from Youngstown, OH
Coming from the banking industry for more than 31 years, where and spent most of those years in the mortgage division. During that time I worked with a lot of great professionals, both internally and externally. I found myself working with Tibitha Matheney, owner-operator of 21st Century, Lakeside Reality. A real estate pro that has a knack for getting the job done.
Recently Tibitha listed a property for my wife and me. From the jumpstart, she was informative and knowledgeable about the neighborhood. During the process she made us feel like we were part of her team. She was always available to answer calls and provide updates on a regular basis. We liked the fact that she has a team approach and that she has the resources available to get your home ready for market. We are happy with the level of service she provided and recommend to anyone who is looking to purchase or sell their home that Tibitha is the real estate professional that you can trust and rely on.
Coming from the banking industry for more than 31 years, where and spent most of those years in the mortgage division. During that time I worked with a lot of great professionals, both internally and externally. I found myself working with Tibitha Matheney, owner-operator of 21st Century, Lakeside Reality. A real estate pro that has a knack for getting the job done. Recently Tibitha listed a property for my wife and me. From the jumpstart, she was informative and knowledgeable about the neighborhood. During the process she made us feel like we were part of her team. She was always available to answer calls and provide updates on a regular basis. We liked the fact that she has a team approach and that she has the resources available to get your home ready for market. We are happy with the level of service she provided and recommend to anyone who is looking to purchase or sell their home that Tibitha is the real estate professional that you can trust and rely on. 2023
Tibitha is amazing! She was helpful and patient as we looked at MANY houses before we found the one we loved. She was willing to travel to the areas we wanted and spend an entire day looking at house after house! While looking at houses she pointed out things we may not have noticed, which was super helpful! She pushed to make our goals happen and get us in the house as quickly as possible. She is awesome! 2022
Tibitha was absolutely amazing! She helped us through the entire process step by step. She was helpful and patient as we looked at many houses before we found the one we loved. While house hunting, she pointed out things at each house that we may not have noticed, which was super helpful! She pushed to make our goals happen and get us in the house as quickly as possible. She is awesome! 2022
Isabel Pagan Canfield Oh., a buyer from Canfield, OH
You are truly amazing and wonderful person to work with
The response time from tibby is second to none. She went above and beyond for my wife and I. From friends of ours who have used different realtors I myself wanted someone who was honest and upfront no matter what the answer was and I found that in tibby. She really does look out for your best interest not just another home to purchase and lays out multiple scenarios for you to review.
Tibby really put her all into the purchase of our home. She made us feel like family and always made sure to fully explain how and why she took the steps she did to get us closer to our final decisions.
Tibi was prompt, professional and did her job extremely well. I would be happy to recommend Tibitha to anyone anytime.
Theresa Noel, Youngstown, OH, a seller from Youngstown, OH
My experience with Tibitha was top notch and I will recommend her to everyone I know.
I used my son's strong recommendation of Tibitha for my housing needs and I will always use her from now on. She was professional and knowledgeable in selling my house quickly.
Tibitha is the best real estate agent I've ever worked with. She is professional, patient, and super educated in how to best list and sell a home. She helped my mother so much in selling her home and we would recommend her to anyone thinking of buying or selling a home. 2022
She is responsive and quick to help at all times. We were selling and buying a home and she helped us with both. She was professional, kind, friendly, and got the job done. We recommend her to anyone she is wonderful. 2022
Agent didnt try to pressure me into looking at anything just sent some new or recently reduced houses and I like that. The high pressure crap isnt my cup of tea. Agent made sure to respond when I had questions or concerns and didnt stress that I kept texting over small stuff. I like that Tibitha provided her professional opinion and gave answers to questions I didn't realize I even had.
A true pleasure to work with!
David Burnside, Austintown, a buyer from Youngstown, OH
There is never anything to worry about when working with Tibi. Not only is she the best agent around, but she is your advocate as well. She will work and fight to get you the best of every part of your deal, even things you didn't knowe you needed.
Jacqueline Sauerwein Leetonia, a seller from Leetonia, OH
She was friendly and down to earth. She made me feel right at ease.
Tibitha is amazing! She has someone to help you When she cant be in two places at once! She helped us through every stage of the process including helping us light a fire under our lender to get things moving. You wont find a better, more experienced and attentive agent. 2022
We had a lot of hurdles to overcome with selling our old house and buying our new one. Tibitha hung in there through all of it and went above and beyond with helping us. She was always available to answer questions and was quick to respond. We couldn't be happier. 2022
Suzanne Humberson Austintown , a buyer from North Lima, OH
Tibi Matheney was a joy to work with. She was good to give us advice on what we needed to do and how we needed to go about it. She was always respectful and returned our calls and texts immediately. She put our mind at ease on all aspects of the transactions.
Both my daughter and I have worked with Tibitha for both buying and selling. Tibitha is an amazing realtor. She was so helpful and honest. She was always available - even when she was on vacation camping! She is so professional, and really knows this business - especially in these crazy markets. I trust her completely, and would never use anyone else. I highly recommend her. 2022
Both my daughter and I have worked with Tibitha to both buy and sell homes. She is a skilled professional. She has been both honest and helpful to us. I would never use anyone else, and I highly recommend her. She is the best! 2022
Matt Kluchar, Canfield, a seller from Canfield, OH
Tibitha has been the best agent I have worked with in every way.
Nicole Pickens, Youngstown, OH, a buyer from Youngstown, OH
Tibi Matheney was great at supporting us in buying our first home. Her knowledge and expertise, and her kindness, helped bring us through the process with a minimum of stress and plenty of joy.
David & Becky Peattie, a buyer from Youngstown, OH
She had our attention throughout the whole process for wanting the house we got. It was a pleasure to work with her. Thank you Tibi for your hard work and dedication.
Tibitha helped me buy my house so when I had to sell it I knew I had to have her help me once again. She is knowledgeable and considerate with my needs and wants with the house. Very speedy responses and answered all my questions I had along the way.
Dorinda Sternburg, Canfield , a buyer from Canfield, OH
Tibi is simply the best!!! I highly recommend her!!
She is responsive, extremely respectful of people and properties and overall a pleasure to deal with!!
The purchase of my mother's new home was done while she was dealing with a serious health issue. It was a stressful time and could have been more so had it not been for Tibi! She made everything as easy as possible, provided the guidance we needed and removed the worries that we might have had to deal with!
Amy Fields, Austintown, a buyer from Youngstown, OH
Tibi came highly recommended and we were more than pleased with how hard she worked with us and for us. I absolutely would let anyone know to use her, she's so professional, kind, hard working, thorough, she follows through and was there for us every step of the way.
Tibi is an experienced agent with 19 years in the business. She knows the area well. She distinguishes herself by providing a personal business relationship with her clients.
Our recent experience with Tibby was amazing! She absolutely knows the market, she was so quick to book showings and was there every single step of the way. Never once was I confused about our home buying process, her clear communication was so professional. I absolutely recommend her for your next home buying or selling journey. I wouldn't want to work with anyone else! 2022
Tibitha was great and easy to work with. As out of town buyers it was great to Tibitha and her expertise to rely on during the buying process. She was also able to connect us with home inspectors and structural engineers for the property inspection. 2022
Tibi brought in a photographer that did a great photo presentation of the condo.
Very professional, extremely knowledgeable of the market values.
Very personable, kept me informed throughout the entire process. It was a difficult time, considering both of my parents died within two months of each other. She made the process run smoothly. I will recommend her to friends.
Tibitha was amazing! Professional, responsive, organized and on top of things! She helped us negotiate with the seller to get the best deal possible and meet our loan conditions. Shes amazing, you truly cant go wrong with someone who genuinely cares about their clients like she does. 2022
Justin wagner canfield ohio, a buyer from Canfield, OH
In a industry that is so busy right now. Most agents treat you like just a number. Tibitha is the opposite she makes you feel like your her only client. While working hard to find you what you need and comes up with creative ways to get the property in contract and see it thru all way to closing.
Tibitha is a pleasure to work with. She is prompt, professional, and she follows through with her words; she gets the job done. After working with her on my first deal, I made her part of my real estate team, my realtor for Ohio. 2022
Good knowledgeable person to work with. Got a lot of things worked out when I was buying my house that maybe someone less knowledgably would not have been able to work through. 2022
Tibitha was super helpful and made the buying process fun. She always got us in to see homes super quick and was easy to work with. She was knowledgeable and professional and we never felt pressured by her. 2022
Tibitha was helpful in our buying process, knowledgeable in real estate. She was super easy to work and get along with and was always quick to get us into houses when they became available. She made buying and selling easy! 2022
This was my first time selling a home and Tibitha was there every step of the way to make sure I understood risks and guide me through it. Shes extremely knowledgeable and goes above and beyond whats expected. It was a pleasure working with her. 2022
Tibitha is the absolute best. 100% she loves what she does, and it shows! From keeping us in the loop, to explaining things we needed a little more clarity on, she was always on point and fast with responses. You couldnt ask for a better Realtor from submitting a contract to being there at the closing and everything in between. She pours her heart and soul into working for you. We appreciate it. 2022
Tibitha was exceedingly patient with our selling our house under difficult circumstances, and she came through with exactly the right buyers. I could not be more satisfied. 2022
I was fortunate enough to work with Tibitha as a buyer and seller. I cannot recommend her highly enough. She made my experience great. So many times I felt out of my depth and lost and Tibitha was so so helpful. Great experience 2021
Very motivated in the buying and selling of our current and new home. Communication skills are fantastic. Willing to go the extra mile to make sure projects are done. 2021
Our experience was made was made so much easier due to Tibitha being so knowledgeable about the selling and buying of homes in today's market. She gave us an honest opinion everytime we asked, and it was much appreciated ! She is extremely Personable, and always made us feel like we are her most important client! 2021
My wife and I had a great experience working with Tibitha. She helped us sell our previous home and buy our current home. She was easy to work with, always available for a question, and made sure we saw every home we were interested in. She helped us get through our somewhat unique situation relatively stress free. We would not hesitate to recommend her to anyone in the future. 2021
As first time home buyers, my fianc and I knew nothing about purchasing a home. We didnt know where to start. Not only did we have zero home buying experience, but we were also told by everyone that wed never be able to find a house in this crazy market! Tibitha was recommended to us by a friend who purchased and sold a house with Tibitha before. Immediately after we began working with Tibby, all of our worries were lifted. Tibby worked day and night for us, seemingly around the clock. As we looked at houses ( it feels like hundreds) she helped us look for the things we love, while also pointing out things that we should avoid. Her expertise is unmatched and her perspective was invaluable. She is professional, honest, and warm. She answered every text and returned every call. And once we found the house we loved, Tibby went to bat for us (and hit a home run!) I would not trust another person to buy or sell a house, and I can guarantee she will be my go-to for all my future realty needs! 2021
My experience with Tibitha was great. She aided me in buying my new home and couldn't be happier with the service received with her. She was honest and upfront and I highly recommend her if you are looking to purchase a home. 2021
Tibitha is the best realtor! She was super helpful and has the clients best interests at heart! She helped us buy and sell a home. Would highly recommend. 2021
Working with Tibitha was the first and best decision I made throughout my home buying process. As a Youngstown native, I was aware of her from local advertising; however, what you see does not begin to define the quality service, you will get. The flow of constant communication with Tibi every step of the way was phenomenal. She will answer all your questions, reach out to your sources and be 110% upfront and honest with you. No hidden fees, no surprises. She absolutely goes above and beyond to get her clients what they want. I would highly recommend her services to anyone looking to buy a home, and will definitely use her again! 2020
Could Not Ask for Better, a buyer from Canfield, OH
When it came to the perfect realtor for our family, Tibitha was the answer! Tibitha not only worked around our schedule, but she worked with our family. When we were looking at houses, she made it a whole family experience (to include our two young kids who were often tired, hungry or bored.) nTibitha really listened to what we said and reacted. Her negotiation skills were on point and she was honest and up front with us. She fought for us when needed and we could not be happier with the results. nNot only did Tibitha find us our new home - but she also sold our old house in less than 3 months when it was previously listed for a year! She worked hard to bring traffic in and tld us the dos and don'ts to get it sold. She was honest and did not set expectations so high that they could not be achieved. nWe recommend Tibitha to everyone we know! We will not work with anyone else. 2016
My husband and I absolutely loved working with Tibitha! She has the best personality and we actually miss talking to her every day! Tibitha did everything she could to help us find our perfect first home. She was informative and professional. Her quick responses helped decrease a lot of the stress caused by purchasing a home. She always made sure we were aware of exactly what was going on and resolved so many issues for us. I would highly recommend Tibitha to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. Purchasing a home became a lot more fun and less stressful because of Tibitha! 2017
My wife and I highly recommend Tibitha! She has a personality that makes you feel like you've known her for years! Every house she took us to see was such an informative experience! She took the time to look through the house with us and really cared about our wants and needs she not only pointed out the good parts about the home but she also pointed out the areas that might not work for our family. We really felt like she cared about our family and genuinely wanted our first home purchase to be a great experience! Even though our lender gave us some hoops to jump through we never felt like Tibitha wasn't understanding or in our corner! HIGHLY recommend her! 2017
Moved Across Country, a seller from Youngstown, OH
Tibitha was fantastic! I was concerned because I moved across the country and needed to sell my first home. I had never gone through the process but she was a terrific guide and assisted me with any questions or concerns that I had. She was considerate of my wants and needs when it came to selling my family home! Even with the inconvenient time difference and my hectic work schedule she was always quick to respond. Most importantly she was dedicated to giving me the best experience in selling my first home and sold it quickly! Thank you Tibitha!!!!! 2017
Working with Tibitha Matheney to sell my home was a 100% positive experience. She was kind, patient, professional, experienced, highly skilled, energetic and motivated. She responded to me promptly via phone, text or email. She was respectful and considerate of my needs and opinions. Although I do not plan on ever selling a home again, if I did...I would make only one call...and that would be to Tibitha Matheney. 2017
Tibitha, did an excellent job with market analysis to arrive at a realistic sales price. Additionally, her social media skills led to a quickly negotiated contract. As a former VP Manager of residential lending at major banks for over 35 years, I was impressed with her efficiency and knowledge. I would highly recommend her to anyone! 2016
Tibitha was fantastic to work with. She was so patient. Must have shown me 10 homes in one day that were on my list. Ultimately, on the same day, she found me the perfect home from her list. It's now home sweet home. 2010
Tibitha is a wonderful realtor!! She is knowledgeable and patient. She knows her job inside and out!! This was my first time buying a house and Tibitha was patient and understanding. She made the process go smoothly!! I would absolutely recommend her to anyone!! 2016
We were somewhat difficult buyers as our search criteria evolved during our house hunt but Tibitha hung in there with us and helped to guide nus through it. She was both professional and knowledgeable and we would recommend her to friends and family. 2015
I absolutely LOVED working with Tibitha. We actually ended up looking for houses for three years due to bank issues and other problems but Tibitha was always warm and welcoming and professional. She was accommodating to my children and found my husband and I that we both could agree on! 2012