This agent has 19 reviews.


Patrick McKone, a seller from Oshkosh, WI
Bethany was a pleasure to work with. Unparalleled professionalism and knowledge. She still plies us with treats to this day.
2020
Paul and Christina, a buyer from Saint Cloud, WI
Crossed every t, dotted every i. Thorough and professional. We much appreciated working with Bethany for her attention to detail and attentiveness. She communicated constantly and everyone was on the same page. It was a really good experience.
2023
the Trautmanns, a seller from Fond du Lac, WI
We sold our home this year with Bethany Warntjes and I just want everyone to know how amazing of a realtor she is. Our story starts long before the sale. 2+ years. & first and foremost her patience with people (whether buying or selling) is unreal. She understands that a home is a HUGE decision and she is understanding and kind as you weight options, go back and forth on a decision, etc.......

Bethany is out of this world talented in what she does. She is detailed, professional, and honestly so involved in every step of your buying/selling.

I cannot wait to work with her again, WAYYYYYYY down the road having just moved, ha, but I cannot recommend her enough whether buying your first home or a second vaca home and anything in between.

One more thing..... Bethany meeting you where you are at. She does not judge your budget, current home or lack of, your lifestyle, your pets, etc.... I literally felt like she respected us, appreciated the business, and was working for us the entire time.

Buying or selling - contact her ASAP.
2023
Mary B, a buyer from Malone, WI
We were recommended by our daughter in-law because friends had loved her. We were not disappointed. Bethanys professionalism is full circle. She will not disappoint! In this hard market she walked us thru every detail. We are so grateful to her and for her encouragement to hang in there. Forever grateful
2023
Jay, a seller from Fond du Lac, WI
I could not express how wonderful Bethany was during the sale of my house. She was professional, understanding, informative and right on track with what would or could happen. She is extremely intelligent and has a strong sense of the pulse within the market. This May all sound pretentious, but before you judge my opinion, call her you will see what I am talking about.
2023
Katie M, a buyer from Neenah, WI
I had the pleasure of working with Bethany to find a home in Wisconsin while I was still in Florida, and I couldn't be happier with the experience. Bethany's dedication and commitment to her clients truly set her apart. Her communication was exceptional, and she went above and beyond to ensure a smooth process all the way to closing. If you're in the market for a new home, I highly recommend giving Bethany a call. She's an outstanding agent who will make your home-buying journey a breeze!
2023
Hanna, a buyer from Fond du Lac, WI
Bethany is a pleasure to work with! She is responsive and informative! Not only will she work with your schedule, but she really cares about finding you a good match in a home. Highly recommend.
2022
Melanie Goeckerman , a seller from Fond du Lac, WI
Bethany is a phenomenal realtor. She is on the ball. She follows through on every detail. Im confident that whether she is selling a $100,000 or a 1 million dollar property that she will be give 100% dedication to making the customer happy. Even in this market, she never assumed she had it in the bag. I would recommend her to anyone buying or selling.
2022
BW, a seller from New Holstein, WI
Did a great job. Helpful, in professional, on top of everything that helped sell our home.
2022
Elijah, a buyer from Fond du Lac, WI
Bethany really put in the extra mile for us. We were on a time crunch in a hot market and she went over and above to get our family into a home that we love! As a first time homebuyer she also made everything easy for us to follow and helped along every step of the way!
2022
Mary, a seller from Fond du Lac, WI
Bethany is an excellent agent. She is highly reliable and always professional. She goes above and beyond to assist you in the real estate process. I would recommend Bethany to anyone and would not hesitate to call on her in the future! She offers complete and thorough information that truly covers all aspects of the buying and/or selling process.
2022
Amy, a buyer from Fond du Lac, WI
Bethany was a joy to work with! She kindly and competently guided me through the entire process of my home purchase in a new city. She notified me of homes that would be of interest to me, including the home I eventually purchased. Bethany was efficient, and took true joy in helping me find my house. She is an excellent realtor, and I would strongly recommend her.
2021
Amanda E, a buyer from Waupun, WI
Bethany went above and beyond to help us find our home! She made our experience stress free! We highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell!
2021
Colleen, a buyer from Menasha, WI
Relocation is stressful and you need someone that pays attention to the details to make sure it goes smoothly.
Bethany is that person.
When you are hunting for a house and starting a new job - making sure the is are dotted and the ts are crossed is challenging. This is where Bethany excels.
She listens - when often times so many arent.
She catches the little details.
She worked hard to find us a house - and made sure it closed. On time.
If you need someone that will listen, focus on the details and through it all - remain patient - Bethany is your person.
2021
Dustin, a seller from Fond du Lac, WI
Bethany really changed my mind about Realtors. Sometimes my search was slow paced and she totally understood that. Once the offer was put in, she worked like lightning and at all hours. It was really appreciated and I can't thank and recommend her enough.

Brian, a seller from Fond du Lac, WI
Bethany does a great job! I have worked with her for purchasing two properties and definitely recommend working with her! She went above and beyond to make sure all the loose ends are tied up and got the properties to closing.
2020
Alec, a seller from Appleton, WI
We were looking for a house in Appleton during a time when the housing market was hot. We worked with Bethany and she found a house we loved. She was flexible with her time and we were able to quickly put in an offer to get the house. She showed she was knowledgeable about houses, the area, and the whole home buying experience. I would highly recommend her as a realtor.
2020
Happy Transplant, a buyer from Fond Du Lac, WI
Bethany was absolutely amazing! She worked with us for 7 months to find the right house for us. We were able to find a home in our price range that would be acceptable for VA financing. It was a long process and Bethany stayed positive and professional the whole time! When we were getting close to closing we had some issues arise and Bethany worked tirelessly to get those things taken care of for us so that we closed on time. I was in shock that someone would go that above and beyond for our family, it is so rare! If you want an honest, hardworking agent who knows this area and the people who can get things done, then Bethany is your best choice.
2020
Adam, a seller from Fond du Lac, WI
First off lets get this amazing woman a raise. Bethany was great to work with. Very informative and constantly kept me up to date with the latest news, feedback, thoughts, etc... She stuck to her word on everything she said she would do and was punctual in doing so. I tried 3 other realtors prior to finding bethany and she could single handedly put the other 3 out of buisness. She sold my house in less than 2 months of listing. Much respect to her as a person, her passion in her career, and the drive she put forth. I wish her the best of luck moving forward and I hope to work with her again. A++++
2019