This agent has 119 reviews.


Tim, a seller from Howells, NY
Laurel went above and beyond selling our home.
We already moved out of our home before listing it. Laurel helped us check on the house, made countless visits to dump out the basement dehumidifier, and even made trips to town hall to submit documents on our behalf.
She was extremely responsive throughout the whole process and always kept us updated.
I would recommend Laurel to anyone looking to sell their home.
2021
Katie, a buyer from Westtown, NY
Laurel was AMAZING! As soon as we reached out the first time, Laurel was quick to respond and learn about what we wanted in our first home. She kept it real with us about the market and was supportive in every decision we made. The entire process was so smooth and we were able to close quickly and without issue. Laurel is so knowledgeable about the realty field and we clicked as soon as we met! Even after the closing, Laurel has been responsive to our questions and continues to work with us. I am so glad we used Laurel to settle into our first dream home!
2020
Omi, a buyer from Harriman, NY
A must read!

Where to begin with my experience with Laurel! I have to say I never quite got the concept of a real estate agent until I needed one. I also didnt understand the motivation behind helping someone embark on a search that may result in nothing and thus the agents effort is all for nothing. Well, this was what I was thinking going into this process, my husband and I, though ready, was equally ready to settle for apartment dwelling yet another cycle, if faced with too many complexities.
Little did I know that I would find a gem, a friend, and a family in Laurel! She came recommended by my sister who got her home about a few years back and surely upon meeting her it was a family reunion - we started thinking we had all the time in the world to find something (i.e., 2019 December) until the unprecedented challenges of COVID-19 began in March / April 2020. Inventory was slim and most of the choices just did not fit the bill. Laurel throughout was patient, available, and just comfortable to talk to. Laurels personality is inherently to care, we experienced the uniqueness of looking at homes in a COVID situation together with the unsettling overpriced houses, slimmed down house viewing, multi-offers on properties that just didnt warrant it etc. and right when we thought we were getting into the grove of things, my husband and I discovered we were expecting! So now we just couldnt settle for an apartment dwelling and the urgency of finding the ideal place that we could grow into became more real.
Amidst all this Laurel, had enough encouragement for all of us, reassuring and never compromising her promise to find us a place that fit the bill of what we wanted. In fact right before the lock-down there had been a home of interest which was already in a bid battle as much as I thought I loved the home and was willing to pay the rising tag on the house for fear of not finding anything else, Laurel advised against it, with her expertise and background she convinced me that it is significantly overpriced above value and all this because of COVID but she still had hopes that we would find even better... glad I stuck to her advice!
Eventually we found the one, while it appeared to fit the bill, there were a lot of unfinished things and an easement driveway that was not mentioned to boot - we were certain we would drop this one, in fact Laurel, my husband, and I came to the consensus that though it seemed to be the one, there were just too many things undone about the home that would elevate the costs beyond our threshold. Long story short, and after some weeks away from this home with yet slim pickings - I came back to the house, Laurel and my husband both reluctant, but on speaking with Laurel that this was it, she rolled up her family sleeves and began working with us on the best way to negotiate this home I have to say without Laurel this process would have been unpleasant nor would we have gotten the deal price we got for it.
In the midst of construction work and finishing touches on the house, personal things happened that I would have been quite alright if Laurel chose to bow out of the process, but to my humbled and most grateful surprise she stood with us. Laurel, little did you know that this gesture of yours, in this personal period for you, endeared you to me more than youll ever know and I knew for sure that you were God-sent.
Laurel your diligence is commendable, I always say what is worth doing, is worth doing well, and you exceeded all our expectations on all fronts. I pray for you like I do family and wish that your good works and attitude and fairness and integrity will always meet you ahead multi-folds. I would go through this process with again and for future if ever there is a need but honestly you came through and supported my vision and interests with grace. As we wait for our little one I can only thank you sorry it took so long to write this I promised myself it must be the first thing I do, when I start extended leave! glad I didnt make a liar out of myself! you are Loved and yes we survived our first snow and our easement neighbors are equally God sent!

2020
Michele, a seller from Otisville, NY
Laurel Lustgarten is the best realtor I have ever worked with. Her professionalism, honesty and integrity outshine any past realtor I have encountered. Laurel goes far beyond the call of duty and always returns phone calls and text messages promptly. Not only did she set the right price for my house but also gave me several suggestions on how to make my home more salable. As a result, the first weekend I put the house on the market, I had numerous offers way above the asking price. Laurel's involvement with the sale did not stop there. Laurel put my mind at ease and held my hand through every step of the process. Laurel was recommended to me by someone whose opinion I highly value and I was not disappointed. I highly recommend Laurel to anyone who is seriously considering selling your home. Your home will be sold!
2020
Deborah W., a seller from New Windsor, NY
Thank you once again Laurel for your professionalism and your absolute brilliance in marketing my mother's home during these extraordinary times we are currently living in. I have worked with you both selling and buying real estate over the past 15 years and I can say with complete confidence that you are AMAZING!!!!! I cannot say enough great things about working with you!!! You will always be my #1 Realtor!!!! Thank you for your compassion and your passion to get the job done and done right!!!!
2020
anita serpentini morino, a seller from Middletown, NY
I am so glad that we chose Laurel . She was the BEST! she was always available for questions and concerns . She knows her business . I would recommend her to anyone looking for an agent . I would also use her again if I ever moved back to the area . She is A+ in my book .

Laurel is the best broker I have ever used

Mima & Louis Dinetz, a seller from Port Jervis, NY
We have completed numerous home purchase and sale transactions over the past 40 years. During that time, we have been assisted, mostly by extremely able and successful real estate professionals, and have come to expect the highest quality of professional support.

Without a doubt, Laurel Lustgarten exceeded all our expectations, and has been the best informed, most effective communicator, while demonstrating the highest standards of integrity. She never failed to respond in a timely manner to our questions, whether by phone, text message or email. She kept us updated daily, and more often when necessary.

Laurel was easy to talk to and patient. Her extremely hard work, combined with exceptional enthusiasm and initiative are unmatched by any standard! Whenever a problem arose, she made sure no one dropped the ball and kept everything moving forward we thought she was exceptional in that capacity. We always felt that she was on our team, totally dedicated and committed to watching out for our interests 24/7!

Laurel prepared an outstanding description of our property and an incredible marketing plan that quickly identified and delivered potential buyers, helping us obtain the best price for our home, within a short timeframe.

We give her the highest recommendation possible.


Deborah Eberhardt, Chester NY, a seller from Middletown, NY
Laurel did a fabulous job marketing and selling our home. She is so conscientious of every detail and extremely thorough. I highly recommend her to anyone looking to sell their home. She made the whole experience so much easier than I thought it would be. Her experience and expertise in the real estate market are exceptional.

Fred Widman, Chester, NY, a seller from Chester, NY
In summary, I would highly recommend Laurel to anyone who is in the need of an agent to assist with the selling their house.
She was wonderful to work with and was receptive to my thoughts and opinions. She was always accessible when I had questions. Her friendly, caring knowledgeable and professional approach to understanding the personality and character of my house led me to feel that she really understood my feelings about this house.
I interviewed several other agents before selecting Laurel. All being the same commission rate. I selected Laurel not only for her warm, honest and knowledgeable approach to the selling of my home but, she also provided recommendations for professionals that assisted me in getting my home ready for sale. I have also used one individual for work in my new home.
In conclusion, I enjoyed working with Laurel and would HIGHLY recommend her.
Thank you,
Fred Widman

Joan Springett-Coscia, Monroe, NY, a seller from Monroe, NY
Laurel Lustgarten is, by far, the only person you need to sell your home! Her experience and guidance are exactly the combination I needed to receive full asking price in less than a week. Anyone who wants a caring and understanding realtor to sell their home does NOT need to look any further with Laurel! She gets 10 out of 5 stars from this happy seller!

S. Ronan, a buyer from Warwick, NY
I am so happy that Laurel Lustgarten was recommended to me when I started looking for a new home. She was professional, friendly, helpful, and stayed on top of things without getting pushy. She made the whole process easy and enjoyable. She got the job done quickly and efficiently. I have already recommended her to a friend and will continue to give her name to others looking for a home in this area. She's terrific!

Neil & Kathy Sullivan, Campbell Hall, NY, a seller from Campbell Hall, NY
LAUREL LUSTGARTEN is a high caliber sales professional that can be relied upon to deliver the best possible outcome for the sale of the client's home.

Majid M, Middletown, a seller from Middletown, NY
Laurel was an amazing agent. She is knowledgeable, patient, responsive, and a pleasure to work with. Laurel responded to phone calls and emails within a short period of time, and there was never any hesitation in answering questions. In my opinion, if Laurel was not our agent, i dont believe the process would have been so smooth. Laurel made made my wife and I feel comfortable and relaxed throughout the process. She exceeded our expectations! I would highly recommend her for buying or selling a house.

Jennifer and Harry Mills, Montgomery, a seller from Middletown, NY
Laurel is a pleasure to work with, she keeps the deal moving forward in a stress free way for all parties involved. Would definitely recommend her.

Jose n Liliana n Little Jeremy, a buyer from Monroe, NY
I wish I could provide more than five stars on this platform. Laurel is amazingly professional, a star of her own. As a first time home buyer, she made the process pleasant. She's informative and keeps that line of communication ongoing. Definitely recommendable. Thanks again Laurel, we love our new home.
2019
Theresa and Wilfredo Anselmo ,, a seller from Middletown, NY
Laurel, Willie and I want to thank you for all your hard work ! You are really the best in the business. So grateful to have had you as our agent. Thank you for all the advice and help, without you we could not have had it go quick and so well. Blessed to have met you . May you continue in your successful career and endeavors. The first time we met, we knew you were the agent for us. May all your clients realize how lucky they are to have you working for them! God bless !

Thank you again, Willie and Terri Anselmo

Richard & Patricia Bowens, a seller from Middletown, NY
As a first time home seller, we are so glad that we selected Laurel as our sales agent. She is highly attentive to every detail and was extremely reliable in response time. Laurels marketing plan and strategy was truly individualized to our unique property. She did a market analysis of our home so we could decide on a price, listed my home, helped with staging and was the master in negotiations. Laurel is personable, knowledgeable and a pleasure to do business with. The individual care and attention was over and above. It was a true pleasure working with her. I now recommend Laurel to anyone who is looking for a realtor.

Jackie Riveros- Middletown NY, a buyer from Middletown, NY
After dealing with not so experienced real agents, working with Laurel was a blessing. She is an excellent agent , knowledgeable and has a great personality.

Linda & Weir Sheret 1 Putters Way, a seller from Middletown, NY
Laurel made a frustrating time a delight!!! Selling a home and moving is stressful..she made everything go so smooth...Thank you!!!!!

Lois Ruckert, Middletown, NY, a seller from Middletown, NY
I did not know how to answer the eighth part of this page as I had not dealt with Laurel previously but as I said above two friends had recommended her. My husband and I interviewed Laurel. She came to the appointment with a wealth of experience (platinum ranked agent), she had excellent knowledge of the area, had sold MANY homes in the area (Scotchtown) she had a marketing plan for our home including an accurate time line for listing our property, understood pricing and listened intently to our thoughts, desires and concerns. Her staging suggestions were right on target and by following her suggestions saved the money a "stager "would have charged. Laurel instinctively knew (experience is the best teacher) which house features needed to be addressed and features could remain as is to get the property market ready. For example the kitchen counter area was large- we considered replacing the counter with granite but the counter was in perfect condition, a good neutral color and with a beveled edge. Laurel suggested we leave it as it would take a few weeks to replace and there were few properties on the market in the area so time was of the essence.

When describing Laurel (actually I used these words to a friend yesterday) knowledgeable, professional, understanding of our circumstances, and an EXCELLENT communicator- with us, with the other agent, and with our attorney. Plus, she has a TOTAL awareness of what buyers want and how sellers can get their price. She literally made a difficult situation for us- we had lived in the house for thirty eight years and although we did not want to sell, we needed to sell because we needed to relocate nearer family.

Laurel Lustgarten is "Simply the best" in our opinion. She represents Rand Realty so well. In fact, before we had even closed we recommended Laurel and Rand to a dear family friend and told her our recommendation was without reservation. Laurel has managed to sell this friends home just about as quickly even though the home and the reasons for selling were different.

Amy Sisco, Middletown, a buyer from Middletown, NY
It was our first time experiencing the home buying process and we really needed someone with patience to help guide us and not steer us in the wrong direction. Laurel was recommended through a long time friend and coworker who knew we werent on the same level as our previous realtor.
Laurel was so wonderful with answering any and all questions and became a really great person to rely on. We felt comfortable around her and her persistence really made the overwhelming process of finding a house more bearable because she was doing the heavy lifting. Right up until contracts were signed, she was rooting for us. It was such a great moment for us and I cant thank her enough for doing what felt was like the impossible for us.

Neha, Monroe, a buyer from Monroe, NY
Laurel is a professional. We always felt she had our best interest in mind and felt comfortable making decisions while working with her. She always corresponded in a timely manner and answered all of our questions. We would definitely work with her again and recommend her to family/friends.

JC Perez, Beacon NY, a buyer from Beacon, NY
Laurel goes above and beyond for her clients. She surpassed the role of a realtor, and became a dear friend to my fianc and I. She devotes so much time and effort into her clients, and genuinely has their best interest at heart. It is evident she is just as determined to find the perfect home for her clients as they are. I highly recommend her to anyone who is in need of a realtor. She is kind, caring, trustworthy, and so personable. Although we are ecstatic we found our dream home, I am going to miss spending weekends with her house hunting. She made the stressful experience of buying a home pleasurable and memorable. We will never forget you, Laurel, and we thank you from the bottom of our hearts.

Lola S, Monroe NY, a buyer from Monroe, NY
I had started working with Laurel about a year into us moving to Monroe and knowing we would like to buy. She contacted me via referral exchange, we spoke and was honest about our timing and she was willing to go the extra mile to give us additional financing recommendation and things we could do to get us ready.

Fast forward a year later, I reached back-out to her and we clicked! One outing and she knew exactly what I was looking for and what would make sense! All through the process, remained professional, approachable and always a smile on her! She is timely and she has a wealth of experience about the market and the neighborhoods.

She is just the best at what she does and no doubt a STAR! She is truly an amazing person.

Laura and Ed , a seller from Goshen, NY
Laurel Lustgarten is the best definition of a real-estate Professional. Many choices to choose from with glamor headshots and expensive cars. If you want to get the transaction done done, call Laurel.

Tim Yates, Winston-Salem, NC, a seller from Florida, NY
Laurel has a through understanding of the local real estate market. She is responsive and stays on top a situation until there is a resolution. She will follow through with commitments and make sure all parties are working together. She continues to work on solutions and doesnt let problems stand in the way of progress. I would highly recommend Laurel to represent any seller

Melissa Moore, Middletown, NY, a seller from Middletown, NY
Laurel was amazing! I followed all of her advice on staging my home, and I had a full price offer on the day that it was listed for sale, and received 4 additional full price offers within just a few days of listing. So clearly, all of her advice was spot on! Additionally, Laurel did a great job of helping me to navigate through the somewhat complex process of selling a home in NY state. She took care of everything for me, and did a great job of following up on things. I highly recommend Laurel for your real estate needs!



Holly LaGrotteria, Highland Mills, a seller from Highland Mills, NY
If you want an amazing, professional experience you must work with Laurel Lustgarten! I met Laurel at a staging class in April. After listening to her comments on realistic/cost effective staging, the local market and the wealth of knowledge she would bring to the seller experience I knew I wanted to work with her when I was ready to sell my house. I met with Laurel in August and my house was listed the first week in September. With Laurel's expert guidance in preparing the house I had 4 showings the first week resulting in 3 offers. The accepted offer was $8K over the listing price. Though I had read seller horror stories my experience was far from that. From listing to closing Laurel made sure every detail was addressed. She instinctively customized her communication to my needs which eased the emotional process of selling a house I'd lived in for 17 years. Words cannot express how grateful I am to Laurel for her personalized approach and expertise.

Holly, a seller from Highland Mills, NY
If you want an amazing, professional experience you must work with Laurel! I met Laurel at a staging class in April. After listening to her comments on realistic/cost effective staging, the local market and the wealth of knowledge she would bring to the seller experience I knew I wanted to work with her when I was ready to sell my house. I met with Laurel in August and my house was listed the first week in September. With Laurel's expert guidance in preparing the house I had 4 showings the first week resulting in 3 offers. The accepted offer was $8K over the listing price. Though I had read seller horror stories my experience was far from that. From listing to closing Laurel made sure every detail was addressed. She instinctively customized her communication to my needs which eased the emotional process of selling a house I'd lived in for 17 years. Words cannot express how grateful I am to Laurel for her personalized approach and expertise.
2017
charles slutsky 18 green ct., a seller from Middletown, NY
great in every way!!

Mariela Anglin Middletown, a seller from Middletown, NY
From the moment I met Laurel I felt comfortable with her. I felt that I could trust her completely. She was friendly and I feel that I have a new friend. I would recommend her with out any doubt.

Elizabeth Homenick, a seller from Washingtonville, NY
Laurel Lustgarten is absolutely amazing! Laurel came in and advised which improvement projects would be most beneficial in the sale of the property. Once the work was completed, she had beautiful pictures taken of the property and worked hard to get people through the door. The property had multiple offers by the end of the first full weekend on the market. However, she didn't stop there, she was involved until the closing of the property. I'm not sure Laurel ever rests! I will highly recommend Laurel to anyone looking to buy or sell a property.

Lisa Szymanski Walden NY, a seller from Walden, NY
ABOVE AND BEYOND IS HOW I DESCRIBE LAUREL. I WOULD RECOMEND HER TO ANYONE LOOKING FOR AN AGENT. LAUREL IS HARD WORKING AND GETS THE JOB DONE NO MATTER WHAT IT TAKES. I DON'T THINK SHE SLEEPS....

LAUREL MADE BEAUTIFUL BOOKS TO GIVE TO PEOPLE LOOKING AT my HOUSE. Because NY house is unusual she was there for every showing. Her enthusiasm during the showings resulted in multiple offers.

LAUREL MET ALL MY NEED SO I NEVER HAD TO DEAL WITH ANYONE ELSE.

Frank E. Campbell, a seller from Monroe, NY
From our first contact with Laurel to our last she was always available. She walked us step by step through the selling process. She provided us with the information we needed to sell our home. Laurel went to each and every room and gave us feedback on how to stage our home. She created and printed information booklets for prospected buyers to give out at our open house.She had a video made which we later found out actually sold the house. Her photographer made our house look beautiful. Due to her internal networking she actually had interested buyers lined up for us as soon as the For Sale sign went up. In any event, I had no idea how much actually went into selling a house and was glad to have a professional like Laurel in my corner. I would highly recommend her !

Margery Wadkins, Middletown NY, a seller from Middletown, NY
Laurel Lustgarten is a superior agent. She was always accessible and all of of her advice was spot on. Within a week I had 5 offers and sold for thousands above asking price.



Anonymous Golfer, Middletown, NY, a buyer from Middletown, NY
Laurel Lustgarten is a Knowledgeable, conscientious, talented broker who listens and follows through with a professional approach.

Absolutely the best! New category - Outstanding!

Thomas - Fort Lauderdale, Florida, a seller from Middletown, NY
Laurel was absolutely amazing. We had met with another realtor prior to listing our house with Laurel and the experience was just horrible. Although we knew our house was not in tip top shape and was somewhat dated, Laurel really treated us with respect and guided us every step of the way. Laurel was simply incredible. She did everything she promised and more.

Thomas, a seller from Middletown, NY
Laurel has really been amazing. We had met with another realtor prior to listing our house with Laurel and the experience was just horrible. Although we knew our house was not in tip top shape and was somewhat dated, Laurel really treated us with respect and guided us every step of the way. Laurel was simply incredible. She did everything she promised and more. If you are looking for a top-notch professional you have already found her. She is the best!
2017
Filomena Saponaro, Newburgh, NY, a seller from Newburgh, NY
Laurel was professional in the sale of the home. She recommended how to present the home for buyers and handled many of the obstacles that surfaced extremely well. I would recommend Laurel highly.


Audrey Sagala Otisville, NY, a seller from Pine Island, NY
Laurel is an asset to Rand Realty. She is an expert at what she does. She took the time to listen and really pay attention to details. She sold my family home and spent so much time explaining things to my mom through the whole process. She is the best!

Jean & Miguel Alvarado, Middletown, NY, a seller from Middletown, NY
Laurel Lustgarten is a lovely lady and we were so happy with her performance in selling our house. Laurel's response time is impeccable and she is creative. This was a tense time for us with health issues and road blocks along the way. Laurel was patient, highly knowledgeable, and consistently met our needs

Laurel was professional and responded quickly whether by email or text. She put no pressure on us to keep the house on the market during times when we knew we could not, in good conscience do so. Moreover, she is highly attentive to detail and provided us with great advice on small tasks to help make the home even more marketable.

We are so happy that Laurel answered our lead! Thank you Laurel, yet again!

Kelli - Montgomery, NY, a seller from Montgomery, NY
Laurel was awesome to work with. She is a smart woman and a kind person. She was extremely throughout and detailed. She cared about our needs and went out of her way to sell our home. I would definitely recommend Laurel for any future real estate needs!

VLupian, Johnson NY, a buyer from Westtown, NY
Extremely satisfied with Laurel Lustgarten, she went above and beyond to find my family the perfect home. Shes extremely knowlwdgable and personable. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to purchase a home. She was always on point and on top of all the details of the home purchasing process. Furthermore, she knew exactly what we were looking for and went the extra mile for us. I can't thank her enough for everything she has done.

Eileen Buckley, Monroe, NY, a buyer from Suffern, NY
Laurel Lustgarten is extremely knowledgeable in all aspects of buying and selling a house and was a pleasure to work with.

Patrick cibirka, a buyer from Washingtonville, NY
Lauren did an amazing job! She always kept me in the loop and I had full trust in her. I will recommend to friends and family.

Gail saretto. Middletown, a buyer from Middletown, NY
Laurel is easy to work with. She was spot on in her advice to ready my home for sale. She is highly efficient and excellent in her responsiveness to calls and questions. I found her fun to work with

Eileen Buckley, Harriman,NY, a seller from Harriman, NY
I chose Laurel Lustgarten based on her personality and the rapport that we had at our first meeting. She had an excellent sales record and and was extremely knowledgable.

Dolores Bellone pine Bush,NY, a seller from Pine Bush, NY
Laurel Lustgarten help us to sell our house quick with only a couple hip cups She is a great saleperson nice pitch.
Laurel Lustgarten did a excellent job for us.
I would recommend her to my friends and I already have.

Nicole B, Montgomery NY , a seller from Montgomery, NY
Laurel is reliable, responsive, and always exceeded my expectations!

Laurel was referred to me over 5 years ago to help me find my first home, and she made such a great impression, that I had referred her to many friends/associates that increased her client base, who are also happy. When I called to tell her I want to sell my home, she made an appointment within days, made some recommendations to improve the "look" with a few minor dollars to be spent, we came to an agreement on the listing price, and I had offers the first day on the market, and then it was a bidding war and the house sold for over list price. She is GREAT, and I will continue to refer her business because of her professionalism, knowledge of residential house, and her excellent communication skills!

Deshawn Deliotte n Ateea Williams,, a buyer from Middletown, NY
I have already stated throughout the survey she is great and should anyone need a home Orange County please give her a call. U will be satisfied.

Mia G Florida Ny, a buyer from Central Valley, NY
Laurel Lustgarten is nolegable and consummate professional in every way, she is helpful kind and cares about the your wants and hope in the purchasing for our home. Laurel held our hand through the entire home purchase process from sending us listings , being available to tour house the were on our check list,
Thank you Laurel for all you have done for us in the recent purchase of our first home, I think we couldn't have had anyone else who would have helped us more than you! Your one of the very, best!

Landrea Richards, Middletown , a buyer from Middletown, NY
Laurel Lustgarten was excellent. I would recommend her to any one that is looking for a person that is professional, great personality, always available for questioning and returns your call right away. Laurel was with me from beginning to the end and gave great advice when I needed it with my nervous self lol. Laurel is the best.

Svante Roding, Highland Mills, NY, a seller from Highland Mills, NY
Laurel Lustgarten made a trustworthy impression and showed us a sound marketing plan with professional photographer and the creation of a video, and subsequent booklet/handout to potential buyers.

Laurel was excellent in all aspects of the sales process.

Laurel did an excellent job and contacted us promptly with any potential buyer and progress.

I would highly recommend Laurel Lustgarten to any potential buyer or seller of property.


Bill Ramsay Sun City, Florida, a seller from Monroe, NY
I researched the web for top selling agents in Orange County NY. I was provided with the top four agents all from different agencies. Laurel was the best prepared and most professional of the all of them. She toured the entire house including basement and outdoor storage shed to get a thorough representation of our house. She provided local comps and discussed what range she felt the house would sell. My wife and I immediately felt Laurel was the right agent for us. Through out the entire sale, Laurel set a standard that few of the agents showing our house could begin to compare with.

The first showing produced a local buyer. While we accepted their offer the sale fell through after 5 months of waiting for the buyer to secure his funds for a cash purchase and then we learned he had virtually no credit. Had his agent been as professional and dedicated as Laurel we would not have endured that painful time loss. As winter approached the showings slowed down and Laurel continued to show our house in magazines, direct mail and through contact with every agent that had seen the house. She remain confident and committed selling our house at the price we wanted.

As our house was on the market for nearly a year, Laurel maintained a dedicated mission to find a buyer. We referred her to three other friends and she successfully sold both their houses. We soon saw Laurel more a a friend and confidant then an agent and felt truly blessed that we had made the right choice in selecting her as our agent.

We really had no dialog with the broker staff personally. We dealt with Laurel exclusively except for the few contacts we had with the showing coordinator at Rand who was always professional and able to address any showing issues we had.

For the year that our home was on the market, we entertained 37 showings. Not one of the showing agents demonstrated the professionalism an charisma that Laurel offered. She was always available and helped us stage the house for professional pictures an video and made multiple suggestions for changes to highlight the features of the house. We consider Laurel a friend instead of a contracted agent.

Wes, Middletown, a buyer from Middletown, NY
We were new to the area and didn't know much about it. Laurel was fantastic at helping us learn about the areas we were considering and find the location that best fit our needs. We didn't really know what we wanted at first, but after talking to us and seeing which homes we were interested in, she figured out exactly what we'd like and actually found the home we ended up buying for us! I was really impressed that she proactively identified homes she thought we might be interested in, instead of just pointing us to a website and having us do all of the research on our own.

We were on a tight timeline and Laurel really helped keep us moving along in our purchase. Any time we contacted her, she was always quick to respond.

We would highly recommend Laurel to anyone looking to buy a home!

Antonella Rubino Middletown NY, a buyer from Middletown, NY
Laurel made the entire process of my first time home purchase smooth from beginning to end. She kept me informed & updated at all times on all the steps of the process. Very knowledgeable in all things real estate, great attitude, fantastic follow through skills & endless resources. I was at ease during the entire process. I couldn't recommend her more highly.

Peter Andre - Murrells Inlet, South, a seller from Middletown, NY
My wife and I called Renee Zurlo a friend of many years at Rand Realty. She knew the area where my home was and told me that Laurel Lustgarten was the Rep that I needed. Renee was right. Laurel knows the area, the real estate market in Orange County and knows how to market a home. When you put all that together with her energy and tenacity, your have the best Real Estate agent in Orange County.

Laurel brought the right buyer to my home. It was a smooth transaction and she kept me informed every bit of the way. Laurel has excellent communication skills.

Very happy with Renee Zurlo for suggesting Laurel Lustgarten to handle the sale of my home.

Very positive experience.

She was simply the best. Exceeded our expectations. We had over 42 showings. When things began to slow down, Laurel suggested a change in strategy. She was always on top of the listing.

Bonnie, Pine Bush, a buyer from Pine Bush, NY
Laurel provided superior customer service in all aspects of the home buying process. She knew my needs and wants and helped me find the perfect home. I can't thank her enough.

Ivan & Chastity Washingtonville, a buyer from Washingtonville, NY
My name is Ivan and my wife Chastity decided to move from Brooklyn and look for a home upstate NY. My wife and I stumbled across Laurel and Rand Realty while looking on Zillow for homes. Needless to say we enjoyed the company of Laurel not only as a Real estate agent but also as a friend. She quickly gained our trust through her honesty and excellent recommendations of local resources such as our lawyer and current loan officer. She was excellent at understanding our needs and wants while being able step back and allow us to make really important decisions. We would recommend her to family and friends knowing that she would extend the same professionalism and expertise she did to my wife and I. We hope to continue to have a relationship in the future with Laurel and we are forever grateful for her in helping us get the home of our dreams. Thank You Laurel!!

Maria Ferri, Townof Newburgh, a buyer from Newburgh, NY
As a first time home buyer, Laurel made this process easy for me. She was always there when I needed her & made what could have been a stressful one, a smooth transaction. She was always there with a smile and positive attitude even when things with the bank were taking longer than anticipated.

She answered all my questions without hesitation (even some that may not have been her area of expertise) and she would always give me her honest opinion which was important to me. She always made herself available to me and responded to my emails, calls and texts promptly.

She took excellent care of me as her customer but also made me feel like we were a team! She is not only an exceptional realtor but also a wonderful human being. I will always recommended Laurel to my friends and family looking to buy or sell a home as I know she will treat them as she treated me and they will have a great experience.

THANK YOU LAUREL!!

Ellen & Keith Fessler, Monroe, NY, a seller from Monroe, NY
Laurel Lustgarten was professional, personable and attentive to us and to details. She always responded to emails and phone calls and helped tremendously throughout the selling process. We can't thank her enough!

Laurel's use of a professional photographer to take photos and a video of our home was such a great idea - it's what sold our home to the first couple who came to see it! They saw our home online and drove an hour and a half to see it in person, already loving it!

It's amazing when you use a sales professional like Laurel Lustgarten, who really knows what she's doing, what a difference it make could make. From the photos and videos, to the spiraled book of details and photos of our house available to all who came, Laurel made the selling of our home much easier than we dreamed it could possibly be.







Danielle D-C, a buyer from Middletown, NY
Laurel was outstanding!! Friendly & knowledgeable of the areas we were looking to move to our FIRST home!! She was able to accommodate our needs based on our tight schedules. She was patient and ran us all over from Monroe all the way up to Pine Bush till we found what we wanted. I would highly recommend Laurel to any potential client!!! She is a ROCKSTAR AGENT!!!!



Kevin & Zulay Middletown, New York, a buyer from Middletown, NY
very pleasant experience working with Laurel Lustgarten, she helped and guided us through out the home purchase. will definitely recommend to friends and family

Veronica Lauruska, a seller from Middletown, NY
Laurel never missed a beat. Extremely thorough and dedicated. She puts her heart and soul into every aspect of the sale and is on top of every step along the way. She goes above and beyond while in constant communication.

Daniel Saretto jr. Orange County , a buyer from Circleville, NY
Our experience with Laurel Lustgarten was fantastic! We found her to be knowledgeable with the housing market and school systems. She always made herself available to us and responded to all communications quickly. Most important to us was that we truly felt she had an understanding of our personally specific needs and wants. Furthermore we found her to be extremely levelheaded and easy to work with. She never made us feel pressured or hurried into any decision. Dealing with Laurel Lustgarten was by far the best experience we've ever had with a broker.

The Ambrose Family /Newburgh NY, a seller from Newburgh, NY
Communication and follow up was the best !

If you are looking for great follow up and a great listing plan Laurel lustgsrten is the best and should be your only choice ! Our house sold and closed in no time at all ! You can not afford not to hire her !

Michelle achaff, middletown, ny, a seller from Middletown, NY
We interviewed three brokers and Laurel was by far the most professional and most prepared for our meeting. She spoke knowledgeably and professionally and was straightforward and someone we felt we could work with comfortably. And she gave us all that she promised. She was extremely professional, and responsive. We felt strongly that she was working for us to help us, any questions we had she could answer and answer completely. We love the professional photograph and video, and her marketing approach. Our house sold quickly thanks to her advice and marketing. And I really enjoyed working with her! Laurel is great and I would recommend her highly to anyone

Pat Thornton, Montogomery NY , a seller from Walden, NY
I would highly recommend working with Laurel. She was professional, knowledgeable, and was completely accurate in her representations of what she was going to do. This is the fourth home I have sold and this was by far the best experience I had with a broker!

This home took a few extra months to close because of the relocation company. A sale price was accepted the third week on the market!


Robert McGuckin, Monroe NY, a seller from Monroe, NY
She was professional and knowledgable. Her comments about how to present our home were honest and helpful.

Nancy and John Sernotti, a buyer from Monroe, NY
My husband and I are first time home buyers. We honestly chose Laurel by her reviews on Rand Realty. In speaking with her she made us feel comfortable, there was never pressure or frustration towards us. She was always up front and honest which we admired greatly. She completely accomodated our situation. Laurel made our home buying experience smooth and memorable one. You hear nightmare stories and we certainly did not have that type of experience at all. I would recommend Laurel to anyone I know purchasing or selling a home and we will certainly keep in contact with her for our future needs. The hardest part of this experience will be missing seeing and talking to Laurel regularly.

Laurel was 100% on with everything! She was extremely efficient and handled every situation in a timely manner. Whatever we asked of her she responded and accomodated.

Laurel made this a fantastic experience. She is extremely professional but certainly makes you feel so comfortable and that she is here for you completely. This was a first experience of home buying for us and she guided us through the whole thing and made it all so smooth. Her honesty is an asset she holds that really put my husband and I at ease. We truly appreciated her honesty and advice.

We primarily only dealt with Laurel who was above and beyond!!

As noted in prior comments, Laurel has made this first time buying experience a fantastic smooth event. Never expected it to go so well. We both are so pleased and can't believe it's over.....our first call to start "looking" at houses was Feb 8 approximately and we are already living in our new home and it's June 21!!

Jay .E Goshen,NY, a buyer from Goshen, NY
After meeting with two other broker's, my wife and I determined Laurel Lustgarten was by far the most knowledgeable and professional.

Laurel's attentiveness was absolutely astonishing. She was available at all hours Monday through Sunday no exceptions even on holidays.
The entire process went smoothly from the initial offer to closing, anything that Laurel had anything to do with gave us no issues.

The best part of working with Laurel is her knowledge of all things home related. Laurel knows every step of the home buying process and the contacts to make every step as smooth as possible.

Laurel is generally one of the nicest people I have ever had the pleasure of meeting or working with. Always on time and prepared.

When issues present them selves Laurel will have the solution.

D. Hejnas, Monroe, NY, a buyer from Monroe, NY
Laurel Lustgarten came highly recommended by a home inspector I was working with on another property I was considering. The first time we spoke, she was polite, respectful, and gathered every bit of information from me to narrow down the style of house I was looking for.

Once we had a short list of houses I wanted to see, during the showings Laurel was observant and pointed out a lot of things that I hadn't considered or that I should be aware of. On our second round of showings, we found the house I was looking for and afterwards, she walked me through the entire process and helped me understand what to expect as I was a first time home buyer. She was also available at any time in case I had any questions or concerns and was always sent a text to set up a time to talk in case she was busy with other clients or at a closing.

Once we had an accepted offer, that is when things really started to go sideways. There was an underground oil tank we had requested to be removed, asbestos to be removed or remediated, and termites that were requested to be dealt with. The oil tank took a little while and the termites were not the issue. What happened is the sellers had hired somebody to remediate the asbestos and what we found when we went to check on the progress was amazing. They thought by wrapping a few ends of the asbestos in aluminum foil and some duct tape would be sufficient. Laurel was right back on the phone to the selling broker to inform her that the remediation was not up to our standards and that it needed to be corrected to which it was.

Once all of the requests had been completed, it then became the seller's attorney who wasn't responding to get contracts signed and things in motion. Laurel was all over that for weeks to ensure that all the necessary documentation was completed and returned in a timely manner by keeping the seller's broker informed that the hold up was on their attorney and we were not getting any responses from her.

If it wasn't for Laurel and her abilities to keep me calm and focused, clearly communicate between parties, and get things moving again, I probably would have walked away from this property as anything that could have gone wrong did (and then some). Laurel worked hard to answer all my questions and was there for me any time all the way through closing. I cannot say enough good things about her and I have (and will continue to) recommended her to all of my friends and family who are looking to purchase or sell a house.

Thank you again for helping me find home....

Barbara Cue, a buyer from Middletown, NY
Laurel was always attentive, and always there to answer all of our questions. She Made the process of buying our first home comfortable.

Excellent all around!

John D. Campbell Hall, NY, a seller from Middletown, NY
Every aspect of our interactions with Laurel were positive. She is professional, polite and courteous. She was ALWAYS accessible during the day, at night and on the weekends. Her knowledge of the industry coupled with here professionalism and fantastic personality makes her top notch in my opinion! She's the best.

Richard locke, a buyer from Port Jervis, NY
My first time home buying experience was a remarkable experience all because of of Lural Lustgarten. She allowed to have the flexibility between mine and my wife's needs. Really stirred us in all the right directions while protecting us from bad situations. She was always responsive to ideas and solutions. She also took personal time to answer questions and do research. It was calm in if this house isn't for you we will find another one. She was so knowledgable about all aspects of homes telling us things that would need to be fixed or wouldn't pass inspections. I really could not have imagined buying a house without her.

Susan Herrmann, Goshen NY, a seller from Goshen, NY
There aren't enough words to describe our pleasure in working with Laurel Lustgarten. Laurel came with a detailed plan/presentation that determined an accurate sales price for our house. The online marketing pictures and video tour of our home that she provided was beyond our expectations and generated an abundance of traffic that we needed to find a buyer. Laurel also took the time to personally write a narrative to accompany the video describing the details and attributes of our home. All of these elements were crucial to our sale.

Our path from contract to closing was extremely complicated. It is certain that without Laurel's expertise and her personal contact with the buyer, this deal would not have closed. Her knowledge, support, and savvy advice was invaluable as we moved through the process.

Laurel's handling of her clients with such personal attention, detailed communication and genuine kindness is truly remarkable. She went well above and beyond her professional obligations to help us. Laurel Lustgarten is an extraordinary agent and we recommend her highly to anyone who needs assistance with selling or buying a home. She is, quite frankly, the best!


Joshua James, a buyer from Middletown, NY
Laurel was fantastic, informative , easy to talk to and get in contact with which to me was a must, hard working and kept my best interests in mind to find the perfect house that fit my budget. I would absolutely recommend her to any of my friends and or relatives. As a first time home buyer laurel went above and beyond my expectations

Linda and Ray Dorn, a seller from Monroe, NY

Laurel is a true professional,what a wonderful,caring person who put my husband and I ease when we where selling our home.She was always available to answer our questions,the pictures she took of the house where beautiful. Would recommend Laurel to anyone who was thinking of selling their home. Laurel is a true asset to Rand Realty.Thank you Laurel.


Alexis, Campbell Hall, NY, a buyer from Campbell Hall, NY


Before we found Laurel I sent out a message to 3 different realtors over a holiday weekend and Laurel was the ONLY one to respond to me! Laurel is fantastic. I cannot say enough good things about her. She is literally just a phone call away - and if she's not available immediately she responds quickly! She is honest and straightforward and really works hard to make the entire house buying process flow smoothly!

Randy Templin, Pine Bush, NY , a seller from Pine Bush, NY
I highly recommend Laurel Lustgarten to anyone looking for a true professional to market their home in the Hudson Valley. I was extremely pleased with her efforts to market my home and equally pleased with her work ethic in doing so. The virtual tour and professional photographs she arranged made a great impression upon prospective buyers.

James and Melissa Muise, a buyer from Wallkill, NY
We would never use anybody else in the future, nor would we recommend anybody other than Laurel. She was professional, helpful and always returned our calls. We firmly believe that our process ran as smooth as it did due to Laurel constantly pursuing any matters that had come up and handling them in a timely manner.

It was a pleasure and overall not nearly as stressful as we had anticipated.

Mary Spinks Wurtsboro, NY, a seller from Middletown, NY
I was told that Laurel is aggressive in promoting a property, but not overly "pushy" when it comes to demands on the seller. I was also told that she is willing to work with the seller if there is a conflict in asking price. I was looking for a broker that would promote my property but be kind and understanding at the same time. Laurel met up to all my expectations!

Selling my home was emotional for me. My deceased husband and I built this home in 1985-86, and it held many valuable memories and moments of happiness. Laurel was compassionate and understood fully what a hard decision it was for me to part with my "home" of close to 30 yrs.

Laurel is a gem and makes any seller feel comfortable during a stressful time. She is also right on top of things. What impressed me the most was her accessibility and excellent communication, any time of the day or night.

Laurel Lustgarten is the best!!

E.Ward Washingtonville, NY, a seller from Washingtonville, NY
Laurel is a highly knowledgeable professional who was extremely patient during the whole lengthy selling process.

The Sweed Family , a buyer from Middletown, NY
As first time home buyers, we did not know what to expect or look for in purchasing a home. Laurel Lustgarten has a lot of knowledge of the market!. She went above and beyond for our family every step of the way. She made us feel like we were her number one priority. She made the home buying process as smooth as possible for us; even to getting us in contact with the right people from our mortgage company, to home owners insurance down to our lawyers. They all worked closely together and kept us in the loop on a daily basis. We believe no one could have or would have been a better fit for us. We will be recommending Laurel to all our family and friends.





Helen Hawkes, New Hampton, NY, a seller from South Fallsburg, NY
Laurel Lustgarten is a committed, professional realtor who is a delight to work with while she gets the job done. Her marketing of my property was impressive. The market was lousy, there were tax issues and "lake rights" issues, and it took two years, but I feel we were teammates throughout the process, and she was supportive and positive the whole time.

I would recommend Laurel to anyone, seller or buyer, to make a stressful experience pleasant.

Steve Goldenberg, Ocean Twp. NJ, a seller from Monticello, NY
Laurel was really terrific. We were hesitant to use a broker who was not located in Monticello but she convinced us that she was the one to sell our house and she was right. She understands what needs to be done to sell a house and we had no problem establishing a marketing plan that was ultimately succesful. I would recommend her highly.

Maria H. Rosado - 1191 Broadway,, a seller from Howells, NY
Laurel Lustgarten is professional. She is responsive and understands the housing market. She is helpful in providing hints on how to make the house as attractive as possible and is ready to point out specific upgrades. Laurel is easy to communicate with and her answers and information are honest and straight to the point. I would recommend her without hesitation.




Selena, Washingtonville, a seller from Westtown, NY
This was a sensitive time for my family. No one really wants to sell their home as a short sale. Laurel understood this and worked above and beyond to sell my home, as well as understand the emotional aspect that come with a situation like this. She remained positive and determined.

I needed someone who was truly interested in and understood the needs of my family.

Laurel exceeds expectation!

Diane Middletown, New York, a seller from Middletown, NY
Best way to describe Laurel Lustgarten, she's magic. Her knowledge, high performance skills, and dedication is what gets the job done!

The Hansen's Mamakating, NY, a seller from Middletown, NY
Laurel was spectacular! Her market valuation was spot on and she recommended repairs that added value and expedited the transaction. She facilitated every facet of our transaction seamlessly. Her professionalism was evident in her attention to detail, due diligence and reassuring nature. It is rare to find a professional who is equal parts knowledgeable, compassionate and attentive.

Chen A., a buyer from Middletown, NY
I was impressed with Ms. Lustgarten performance as my agent during my recent search for an investment property. I have been searching for properties for personal and investment purposes for the past 15 years, and worked with many agents over the years. Ms. Lustgarten has proved to be one of the best agents I have had the pleasure to work with. She is professional, punctual, and serious. Her efforts to meet my expectations were genuine, and I was able to find and close on a property I was satisfied with. I am planning to continue my professional relationship with Ms. Lustgarten and highly recommend her as a realestate agent.