This agent has 40 reviews.



Jessica, a buyer from Smithfield, VA
My fianc and I were in the process of searching for our first home when we started working with Katie. As first-time homebuyers, we had a lot of questions and Katie went above and beyond to obtain the information we needed to purchase our home as well as patiently answering each and every question we had. The process was smooth, stress free, and timely due to Katies diligence and experience. She truly is an agent who listens to your wants and needs as well as someone who is with you every step of the way. Her fun and positive attitude made her a joy to work with and her honesty was refreshing. We are now living in the home of our dreams. We would highly recommend Katie Sylstra to anyone interested in purchasing a home!
2020
Michael, a buyer from Hampton, VA
As a first time home buyer I needed guidance on every step of the process. Katie was knowledgeable, attentive, empathetic of my needs, and patient with me.
2020
Jeff C. Mones, a seller from Newport News, VA
What clinched the deal with Kathleen is she was timely in our initial meeting and provided me a "sales" packet of her credentials and what her plans were to sell the house. It was printed out for me to review at my leisure. She was dressed professionally and I could tell she was actually listening to my input re the house sale and those things that were important to me. Excellent realtor/broker. She was always responsive to any of my questions and always followed up.

Tom Rapcavage , a buyer from Yorktown, VA
Couldnt have been better

CAPT James Taylor, USN(Ret) - Lawton,, a seller from Chesapeake, VA
I could go on and on but I don't want to others the misunderstand how much I appreciated Katie's amazing efforts. I had a challenging time with my house through the previous real estate organization in the Tidewater area. I had sleepless nights in Oklahoma because of what they allowed a previous renter to do to my house that caused more than $30,000.00 damage and they would not spend a penny in support to fixing it when it was obvious they did not represent the requirements of our property management contract. I had more challenges with their sales agents in their being dysfunctional and providing excuses rather than solutions in order to not being able to sell my home for too many years. It was a hard lesson for me but why should it have been that way?

In just a matter of a few phone calls, one person-to-person meeting in your office and her true representation of what a real estate agent should be Ms Katie Sylstra exceeded all of my expectations and became a person I could trust with my best interests in selling my home. Her professionalism and personal attention to detail is highly commendable. I feel truly blessed for us to have shared the time we did over the phone, exchanging communications and always staying on point in selling my home.

I will forever be grateful for Ms Katie Sylstra and I wish all the best in her future endeavors. She is an amazing woman and am proud to call her my friend! Thank You Katie Sylstra!!!

Becky OBryan Virginia Beach, a buyer from Virginia Beach, VA
We have worked with Katy as both a seller and buyer. Katie went above and beyond our expectations in both transactions!

Steven Sawyer, a seller from Virginia Beach, VA
I have purchased and sold 5 homes over 20 years in several states. I have used over 10 real estate agents. I fired two prior to hiring Katie. I must say that Katie is by far the best realator I have ever worked with. She is honest, knowledgeable, dedicated, and truly cares about the customer. The vast majority of realtors care about the listing and that is all because they will make money just for the listing. Words alone will never express my grattitide to Katie. I will always tell me friends about her and if I am ever in the market to sell or purchase she is the only person I will trust. Too many realtors are like car sales people but not Katie!

Outstanding in every way!!

A vast majority of other realtor's can take some lessons from Katie! She is amazing!





Steven S., a buyer from Virginia Beach, VA
I typically do not write reviews and if I do, they are not in great detail. I want to share a review on Katie Sylstra because there are too many realtors who really do not take their job seriously or do not care about their clients. Katie is head and shoulders above any realtor I have met or dealt with and I want to share so you can receive the same treatment and service that I have received from Katie.
About two and half years ago we decided to put our house on the market. We went through two realtors who made all kinds of promises but did not deliver. All they cared about was getting the listing. They figured someone else would sell the house and they would still get a commission as a listing agent. We met Katie and decided to give her an opportunity; however, we were hesitant due to the poor experiences we had in the past.
Katie understood that we were uncertain, but she was patient, not pushy, and did not make promises she could not deliver. When we finally decided to list the house, Katie was there to help us every step of the way. She offered suggestions to help the house show better and she also let us borrow some of her personal belongings for staging purposes. After 10 days we received an offer on the house. Unfortunately, due to some reasons we had to take the house off the market and could not accept the offer. When we explained this to Katie, she was more than understanding even though she had spent time and money on listing our home. This was an example of what separated Katie from most other realtors because our experience was that other realtors would have been upset, but not Katie!
Katie continued to stay in touch with us but not in a pushy way at all. She would send us cards periodically and on holidays. We contacted Katie in March 2019 and informed her we were ready to list our house again as well as help me find a house to purchase and my wife since we were separating. We listed our home in April 2019 and had an offer at full asking price in five days!
Katie was more than patient with me when we looked at houses. We visited over 20 homes and not once did Katie get upset or impatient with me. She was always supportive. Since I was purchasing this house on my own, I asked Katie to provide me her opinion on the houses so I would get another perspective. Katies words were valuable to me since she thought of things that would have never crossed my mind. Katies knowledge exceeds that of most other realtors.
Since my wife and I were separating Katie did an excellent job maintaining complete confidentiality. It was refreshing that Katie was professional to respect our unique situation by maintaining a level of trust yet still delivering excellent service to both of us.
In the past twenty years I have used over 10 realtors to either sell or purchase homes in several states and hands down Katie Sylstra is the best! She truly cares about each and everyone of her clients and will go the extra mile to make sure a house sells, or a client finds their dream home! Another key difference between Katie and most other realtors is that Katie is genuine. She treats you like you are her only customer and not a number. In my book, people must earn my trust and Katie has definitely earned mine not by words but by her actions! Katie Sylstra consistently demonstrates superior knowledge, skills and abilities which reflect credit upon herself and set the standards for which all realtors across the country should follow! I am more than confident that Katie is truly the best and if you want the best to help you sell or buy your home, I strongly encourage you to contact her immediately!

2019
Tyler, a buyer from Virginia Beach, VA
5 Stars

Katie went above and beyond our expectations and we now know why she was recommended by my wifes co-workers. From start to finish Katie had a great attitude and was always available to answer the many questions we had about the home buying process. She was able to pick through our wants vs needs in a home and even provided listings that we loved but wouldnt have seen based off our search criteria when looking for homes ourselves. Needless to say she was also able to handle my uncanny humor and ended up finding us the perfect house! Would recommend Katie to anyone looking for or selling a house and will definitely be going back to her for any of our future house buying/selling adventures.
2019
Rose Sculthorpe / Chesapeake , a buyer from Chesapeake, VA
Kathleen Sylstra was helpful and professional. Very knowledgeable about the market. The Biggest thing for me was her caring personality. She was easy to approach with our questions. I would highly recommend her to friends and family.

Dawn Wyatt, Virginia Beach, a seller from Virginia Beach, VA
We loved working with Katie. Although we had strong opinions about everything including photos, sales price etc., we listened to Katie's recommendations and she was so right! We received more for our home than we ever thought possible! She advised about what repairs and improvements we should make long before we ever put the house on the market. She chose the selling price and had amazing professional photographs taken. She even decorated our house with additional touches in areas we had over looked, which contributed to the appeal of our photos and kept our listing in the #1 spot in our category until it sold in only 11 days. She even calmed me in the midst of many rants and hysterical outbursts. Katie handled all interaction with buyers, agents, appraisers, inspectors, contractors etc. We never had to miss work to handle anything on our own unless we chose to. This is our 3rd transaction with Katie and we are planning many more.

Mark Sabater, Va. Beach , a seller from Virginia Beach, VA
Katie took the fear out of us buying and selling a home at the same time. My wife and I had a ton of questions along the way and her knowledge and confidence put our minds at ease time and again. She's incredibly patient and professional. Her online marketing and beautiful staging of our home helped find a buyer within the first few days of listing! You could tell she loves what she does. And when you find an agent like that, you're golden. Thanks Katie!

Becky OBryan, Stafford, VA, a seller from Norfolk, VA
Katie was an exceptional realtor throughout the rehab process and sale of our property. She is an amazing communicator and negotiator and went way above and beyond to facilitate the sale of our house in a timely manner. Katie is a great problem solver and a can do person-all with a smile on her face. I would highly recommend Katie Sylstra to family, friend, and business associates.

Amanda Gramajo Virginia beach, a buyer from Virginia Beach, VA
Katie has worked with us before. She is super dedicated to helping her customers in any way possible! I will continue using her In all of my real estate means. She shows such compassion for what she does and compassion for her clients that its a refreshing breath of air. If it was not for her this process would have been a complete disaster!

Dawson & Nicole, Virginia Beach, a buyer from Virginia Beach, VA
Katie made the selling of our old home and the buying of our new home as stress free as possible. She was always there when we had questions or concerns. She went above and beyond the usual expectations of a realtor.

Katie was truly amazing and I would highly recommend her to anyone who is buying or selling a home.
2018
Darren and Cheryl Johnson Portsmouth VA, a buyer from Portsmouth, VA
We love Katie. She made herself available. It was a stress free enviroment while working with her. No matter when we called with a question she took the time to answer. I will refer her to friends and family.
2018