This agent has 15 reviews.


Elizabeth, a buyer from Fort Collins, CO
Coy was extremely helpful to me in buying a home here in Fort Collins while I still lived out of state. He walked through houses for me, took videos and offered advice before I jumped on a plane to purchase my new home. It was a pleasure to work with him!
2023
MCI, a buyer from Windsor, CO
We first met Coy when we found a house on Realtor.com that we had interest. He was quick to respond and found time to show us the listing right away. Although that home was not the one, Coy proved he was the one to work with. We then began a great partnership working with Coy long distance from Georgia to find our perfect home in Colorado to be close to family. Coy is knowledgeable, has a wonderful easy going nature, and became a trusted friend. He paid attention to the things we asked for, but even heard what we wanted when we didnt express it verbally and each time we talked about house options, he zeroed in on what we were looking for with precision. When we thought we found our new home, he became a great sounding board for us. As it turned out, we lost this house to another buyer, which was devastating, but Coy was certain it happened for a good reason because a better home for us was out there. 1 week later, we were under contract on a house we truly are excited to own! Coy worked effortlessly on our behalf, proved to be a great negotiator, and went the extra mile to do virtual tours with us and take our calls at all hours. This was the best buying experience we e ever had, and it is because Coy was so authentically genuine and great to get to know. We recommend him highly to work with on any side of a real estate transaction. You will be happy you chose to work with Coy!
2023
Zach, a seller from Fort Morgan, CO
Coy was our choice when purchasing this property and he did such an excellent job that we asked him to help sell it when we were ready to move to the next stage of our lives and purchase in a new location. Upon first explaining our situation, Coy immediately outlined our options and possible scenarios that we could pursue. Throughout the entire process, Coy remained professional and used his many years of experience to help navigate us through the negotiation process to complete a successful sale. Coy is also adaptable to his clients in that he will recognize the experience of the client and adapt to accommodate that. He always responded when we needed him and he has always left us feeling satisfied with the final transaction. We highly recommend Coy for all of your NE Co real estate needs!
2023
Mena & James , a buyer from Fort Collins, CO
We are out of state buyers and we took a few trips to find our Fort Collins home. During these visits and in between, Coy patiently helped us navigate the Fort Collins real estate market , gently guided us to find what we needed / wanted and helped us close the deal on our next home. I highly recommend Coy for your buying experience.
2023
Foco family, a buyer from Fort Collins, CO
Coy was responsive to our request for a showing and ended up helping us buy our dream home. Coy and his team were quick with communication and were helpful in the purchasing process.
2023
Kim, a seller from Milliken, CO
This property had several contracts fall through, Coy and his staff were always professional and consistently on top of everything. He kept me informed and updated. I would highly recommend him to any buyer or seller.
2023
John and Lorie, a buyer from Windsor, CO
My wife and I were fortunate to receive a text message from Coy Wylie in response to our first home showing request on Realtor.com one hot summer July evening. The property we saw was a no-go but hooking up with Coy Wylie was the best thing that happened that night. He was always quick to respond to our requests for showings or questions even to the point of pausing his trip home from vacation to send us information about a property we were interested in seeing. Coy was calm, responsive to our needs and he skillfully guided us through the entire home buying process from pre-qualification, to offer letter, through negotiations, to the final closing. Hes also been a knowledgable resource for highly reputable home service providers weeks after closing! We highly recommend Coy Wylie to represent you in your new home search and purchase!
2022
Tristan, a buyer from Idaho Springs, CO
Coy helped me land a great home in Idaho Springs after months of searching and making offers in the hot pandemic market in Fort Collins, Denver, and the mountains. We ran into a significant issue with the sewer line, which Coy helped me navigate while I was living in another state. He's friendly, responsive, professional, knowledgeable, and overall great to work with.
2021
Mike, a seller from Loveland, CO
We were disappointed with using Coy to sell our property. Our property should have sold for much higher then it did. Properties in the same community sold higher and our place was bigger the theirs. He didn't try to get a good price out of our condo. We had it priced right because several people who looked at it, left good comments about the price. Coy didn't look out for us at all. He is a nice guy, but as a realtor, He is well below average. I would suggest using someone with more experience and who will lookout for the seller.
2020
sbiekert, a buyer from Fort Collins, CO
My husband and I met Coy serendipitously through a home listing on Realtor.com. We clicked with him immediately, and he became our agent as buyers. He took us on several showings, always friendly and on time, with no pressure. When we found our new home, he was a great mediator between us and the sellers, and made himself available through email and text anytime we had questions. When it came time to sell our condo shortly after purchasing our new house, he already had a client in mind for the property. I wasnt sure if it would seem contradictory to have him representing both us as sellers and the buyer, but I feel he managed to look out for everyones best interests and keep the negotiations fair. Coy has a huge network and great contacts for basically anything you might need related to buying or selling a home. He is professional but also personable, and we now consider him a friend. I would absolutely recommend Coy and his team if you are looking to buy or sell.
2019
Jeff P., a buyer from Berthoud, CO
We much appreciated our home buying experience, and Coy's excellent expertise. He was responsive, knew the area well, and helped everything go smoothly. No matter what odd question we had he was quick to get a response, and helped guide us through the process. We were never left wondering where we stand, or what we might have forgotten or missed.
2019
Shirley, a buyer from Fort Collins, CO
Coy met and exceeded all our expectations. He worked hard to find the right home for us. He has many contacts in Fort Collins which has been helpful to us during the move. I would highly recommend Coy.
2019
CJC, a buyer from Greeley, CO
Every Realtor should be as professional, knowledgeable and invested as Coy. He helped us find the perfect home for our move from TN to CO.
2019
CJC, a buyer from Greeley, CO
Coy Wylie was the perfect realtor for us! We wanted to move to the Front Range, leaving Tennessee after retirement. Coy asked the right questions and listened to our requirements, providing an excellent portfolio of available homes. After viewing numerous properties, we were Able to find one that meet our needs and fulfilled our vision. After the offer, Coy was thorough in working with us through closing - he made a challenging long distance experience easy. I would recommend Coy Wylie to anyone looking for real estate.
2019
KimK, a buyer from Milliken, CO
I purchased a town home in Milliken from out of state. Coy was extremely accommodating in helping me keep everything on track locally. I would definitely recommend Coy for your buying or selling needs.
2019