This agent has 51 reviews.


Lisa , a seller from Hawley, PA
Sarah Tigue is definitely your Hometown Realtor to call. She knows the Lake Region area so well. She sold my house quickly and with excellent communication. She is a pleasure to work with and her knowledge and experience shows.
I am so glad I called her and I believe you will too.
2023
Ian, a buyer from Paupack, PA
Sarah was wonderful to work with! Extremely knowledgeable about the area and helpful with the whole buying process. She was responsive and answered all of my million questions ! Would recommend for sure.
2023
Karen, a buyer from Lake Ariel, PA
Sarah was amazing!!! She was responsive
And answered all of our questions. She is a pleasure to work with and made the whole process fun! Definitely will use her again!
2023
Karen , a buyer from Lake Ariel, PA
Sarah was amazing! She was responsive
And answered all of our questions. A pleasure to work with! Definitely will use her again!
2023
Judy, a buyer from Hawley, PA
Sarah was a pleasure to work with. Extremely hard working, professional, and knowledgeable. She helped us get the best price for our property and always had our best interests in mind. I would definitely recommend Sarah to anyone searching fir a trustworthy real estate agent.
2023
Melisa Mordenti, a buyer from Hawley, PA
Sarah truly excels at her craft. Her hard working personality, eternal optimism and intimate knowledge of the local real estate market leave you in competent hands. She expertly navigated representing both the sellers and buyer (me!) through the entire transaction and gave clear direction and advice while ensuring fairness for both parties. The end result was truly a lovely shared moment for both families.

I've known Sarah for most of my life so she truly is the "Hometown Girl" to me. But watching her professionalism and expertise the last few years is what really drove my decision to work with her for such a life changing event. If you are thinking about buying, selling or investing in the area, I would recommend her in a heartbeat.
2023
Sharon Albion , a seller from Hawley, PA
From the start, Sarah was wonderful. She was professional yet she was like a family member. She really cared about our well being and throughout did everything possible to get us the best sale she could. She is extremely hard working and honest. I am so happy that she was recommended to us and I would recommend her to everyone.
2023
Tim Petroski, a buyer from Beach Lake, PA
Sarah was AWESOME! She set the bar high with her attention to detail, responsiveness, professionalism, friendliness, and work ethic. I would definitely recommend Sarah in the future and would work with her again if the opportunity ever arises.
2023
RonT22, a seller from Hawley, PA
I accepted a new job offer in another state and was given only two months to sell and relocate. I was skeptical we could sell on short notice in an unstable market. I was proven so wrong by Sarah's ability to market, communicate, and negotiate. Sarah's professionalism comes through the minute you meet her, and her knowledge surpasses any realtor we have worked with. Our house received the eventual selling offer only eight days after going on the market. Sarah's advice on pricing our home was spot-on accurate. There were also many complexities we needed to negotiate during the closing process to remain on my hiring company's schedule as they were paying for the move. Sarah made all the right recommendations and, through my experience of four home sales, this was easily the best. We can't thank you enough Sarah for saving us time, money, and stress during this process!

RonT22, a seller from Hawley, PA
I accepted a new job offer in another state and was given only two months to sell and relocate. I was skeptical we could sell on short notice in an unstable market. I was proven so wrong by Sarah's ability to market, communicate, and negotiate. Sarah's professionalism comes through the minute you meet her, and her knowledge surpasses any realtor we have worked with. Our house received the eventual selling offer only eight days after going on the market. Sarah's advice on pricing our home was spot-on accurate. There were also many complexities we needed to negotiate during the closing process to remain on my hiring company's schedule as they were paying for the move. Sarah made all the right recommendations and, through my experience of four home sales, this was easily the best. We can't thank you enough Sarah for saving us time, money, and stress during this process!
2023
Karon, a seller from Honesdale, PA
What an amazing, painless and seamless experience I had with Sara. From the minute she viewed the home she kept me updated and answered all my questions in a timely manner
She is knowledgeable , engaged and dedicated.

Just a little over a month from listing to closing!! Highly, highly recommend her. Thank you Sara!!
2023
Justin, a seller from Lakeville, PA
I have worked with Sarah before and would highly recommend her. We listed this home, we priced it correctly and received multiple offers within one week. Transaction was smooth and everything worked out on time. Great experience. Justin H.
2023
Montalvo, a buyer from Hawley, PA
We had the pleasure of working with Sarah on our home purchase in Fawn Lake. She was amazing from start to finish. Communication was on point. We trusted her from day one! She continues to be a resource even after we closed! Would highly recommend using her services.
2023
Melissa , a seller from Beach Lake, PA
Sarah was great during the whole process. She was extremely responsive & helped us receive the price we wanted for the sale of our home. We highly recommend her and will continue to use her for any future house sales.
2023
James H, a buyer from Milford, PA
Working with Sarah was a pleasure through my whole searching and buying process. Every question I asked she always had the answer for and there wasnt any doubt. Even when things got down to the wire she worked hard and made everything happen to close on time. I will and would use Sarah again for buying another house!!! 10 out of 10
2023
Stacie Sutton , a buyer from Honesdale, PA
Sarah was great to work with. She was patient with showing us houses. She was knowledgeable about walking me through the entire process. She was available and worked with my work schedule to help us get our forever house. I couldn't have asked for anyone better to help me with this process.
2022
arthur, a buyer from Greentown, PA
Sarah is the best in the business.
Nothing more needs to be said
2022
Simone Pursell, a seller from Hawley, PA
Sarah Tigue get's the job DONE! We had our house Sold in 35 days. Sarah was professional, and knowledgeable. She made the selling process easy. You can always count on honest advice and guidance from Sarah. Communication with Sarah was a pleasure. I highly recommend Sarah Tigue for the job.
Sarah deserves 10 Stars*
2022
Seller, a seller from Greentown, PA
Exceptional in all aspects!
2022
Nancy, a seller from Lakeville, PA
Sarah was amazing! Always available and knowledgeable with this area. I would recommend Sarah to anyone who is buying or selling a home/property.
2022
Morgan Samsell, a seller from Hawley, PA
She was great and sold our house as soon as possible.
2022
Allen & Danielle, a seller from Greentown, PA
Sarah is a ROCKSTAR! Selling a home has been an experience that Sarah made bearable! She was always responsive and comforting during the process! If you need to sell or buy, this is your girl! Local, knowledgeable and capable of making it happen!!
2022
Ashley and Joe Sutton , a buyer from Hawley, PA
Sarah was great from the start. Sarah was patient with us as we looked at a lot of houses, and always there with advice and suggestions on all of the houses we looked at. When we found our house, Sarah was able to negotiate for us throughout the whole process. Sarah was always available, and there to help with any questions and concerns we had throughout the process up to closing. Sarah made the process easy and we couldn't be happier working with her!
2022
Home Buyer , a buyer from Lakeville, PA
Sarah is a fantastic realtor. She goes above and beyond for her clients. If you want someone who is willing to listen & follow up on your questions & concerns, truly working for you then choose Sarah.
2022
Nancy, a seller from Lakeville, PA
Sarah was great and so helpful through the whole process of selling our property. She was accommodating at any time, day or night, to answer any questions or concerns that we had. It was certainly a pleasure and Sarah will be highly recommended.
2022
Daniel Zerafa, a buyer from Honesdale, PA
I just sold/bought my 3rd house with Sarah in just over a year. This last one was a challenging one on the sellers end, and I cant thank Sarah enough for all the time and effort she put in to make sure I got this house. Her knowledge and experience for the housing market in this area is what I believe to be the best we got. Dont hesitate and sell/buy that house with her today!
2022
Amanda, a buyer from Tafton, PA
Sarah was absolutely wonderful all through the purchase of my home. This is my second home purchase (first time using Sarah) and it was by far a better experience than the first due to to her kind heart, knowledge and skills. She is an awesome realtor and lifelong friend. I highly recommend her for your next real estate endeavor!
2022
Lilian Applegate, a buyer from Gouldsboro, PA
Sarah was absolutely incredible and so helpful throughout the entire process of buying my first home. She was willing to do showings at any time was convenient for myself and my family, and was available by text or phone at any time of the day. As a first time home buyer, Sarah helped to relieve so much stress and anxiety throughout the entire process. She is absolutely amazing at what she does (both in real estate and as a nurse) and a truly amazing person, and I make sure to tell anyone I know looking for a house about her!
2021
Roe, a seller from Lake Ariel, PA
Sarah is absolutely amazing! She arranged for repairs, inspections, let movers in to get our furniture, went through a lengthy COVID probate with us after the loss of our mother, and went above and beyond to help us any way needed. Sarah was always accessible by phone and text, and took care of all local things as I live in another state and could not physically be there. She is knowledgable in all aspects of Real Estate. There are not enough words to describe how invaluable she was during our sale. There is no one I would recommend more than Sarah Tigue. She is a true professional as well as an amazing person and we could not have done this without her.
2021
Tom and Rosie Jannazzo, a buyer from Hawley, PA
We would like to let everyone know that our experience working with Sarah was outstanding. We were happy with her ability to show us a wide variety of homes that were in the description of what we were looking for and taking a chance on showing us some that were a little different than what we may have chosen. She is someone that you could actually think of as a friend as well as your agent. We would highly recommend her, she was great! Thank you Sarah for a smooth transition to our new home!
2022
Joanna, a buyer from Greentown, PA
We had a wonderful experience with Sarah. She sent us home after home, and made sure we didnt choose one for the sake of choosing but because it was the right one for us. She read us well and was extremely knowledgeable about this crazy market. As always, there was little hiccup at the walk through and of course she negotiated on our behalf until the end (and while on vacation!)
Tom and I highly recommend her services. Shes a pro, and as important a warm, generous person who was so easy to be around. Thank you Sarah, our new friend!
2022
Danny Zerafa , a seller from Hawley, PA
Sold my house this morning with Sarah and I cannot recommend her enough. She made the whole process quick, easy, and pleasant. She had great communication whenever I had a question or needed help. I, without a doubt, believe she is the best we got in this area!
2021
Kim, a seller from Hawley, PA
Sarah is amazing to work with. She is knowledgeable and responsive, will answer any questions, and always willing to give advice. Definitely recommend!
2021
Dave, a seller from Hawley, PA
Sarah was great to work with. I would recommend her to anyone. Absolute pleasure
2021
Jacqueline Jimenez, a buyer from Honesdale, PA
Sarah was helpful and professional throughout the process. I would absolutely recommend to help someone sell or buy a home. Im grateful I had Sarah to explain things to me and recommend people. Coming from NY I didnt understand the process and Sarah was careful and patient. She is professional, and cares.
2021
Marcel, a seller from Hawley, PA
Sarah was great. She helped me throughout the entire process and was able to connect me with a contractor that got my house looking better for selling.
2021
Ashley, a seller from Hawley, PA
Sarah was great every step of the way with the sale of our house. She always provided us with advice and recommendations, as well as always answered all of our questions, no matter what they were. We enjoyed working with her through the sale and now as we are going through the process of buying a new house.
2021
Aj, a buyer from Hawley, PA
Amazing. Sarah was the first agent that actually listens to us and took us serious. Within a couple of weeks working with her we were able to find out dream. 5 ***** for sure.
2020
Nick & kayla , a buyer from Greentown, PA
Sarah was awsome to work with and did an amazing job helping us become first time home buyers. Made it easy and explained things every step of the way. We 100% recommend if you're looking for a place to call home call Sarah tigue
2020
Brandon D. , a buyer from Hawley, PA
Sarah was an absolute blessing. We had been trying to buy a house for a while and after 4 realtors let us down and just didn't seem interested in helping us, we found a house Sarah had listed and called the number on the sign. We didn't expect her to come right away but within 15 minutes she was there and we had a new realtor and a new friend. Sarah kept our best interest in mind throughout the entire process and always gave us guidance without pushing us in any way. She was a blast to work with. We struck out on a few homes but then she found this house for us and knew that it would be perfect for our growing family. We are so grateful to have had the opportunity to work with her. I cannot say enough good things about Sarah and we will definitely recommend her to anyone we know is looking for a realtor.
2021
Karl M, a seller from Tafton, PA
Sarah did an amazing job. Especially responding to my constant questions. I would 100% recommend her to anyone wanting to buy or sell property.
2020
Courtney , a buyer from Hawley, PA
If I could give Sarah 100 stars instead of 5 for Negotiation Skills, I would. She was patient, always ready to answer questions, or show us houses. When we finally found our dream house, we were ready to offer close to asking and she smiled and said nope! We can do better! Sarah is 100% about the buyers - I cannot recommend her enough.
2021
Mike, a buyer from Honesdale, PA
I reached out to Sarah to help me with my first major real estate purchase. My wife and I were looking for a multi- family with minor upgrades, close to town. We had been working with Sarah for a few months to find exactly what we were looking for but with the market moving as fast as it is, finding exactly what we were looking for seemed almost impossible. This is the part that elevates Sarah to a 5 star PLUS a multi family in town hit the market and was only listed for 3 hours when Sarah discovered it at 11 pm one night and messaged us abut the listing immediately. Sarah set up an appointment for us to see it the following morning and we made an offer on the spot that was not immediately accepted. With some quick thinking and another offer we were able to get EXACTLY what we were looking for under contract in less than 24 hrs of our home hitting the market!! Sarah pays attention to detail, she listens to her clients and knows how the real estate process works and finds exactly what you are looking for. We would not be in our home today if it wasnt for Sarah in our corner.
2021
Magdelena, a seller from Hawley, PA
Sarah is wonderful. She definitely knows what she is doing. She is very
knowledgeable in her field. Sarah sold my home for 100,00.00 more then remax
wanted to list it for. She is a pleasure to work with. Sarah goes above and beyond to
get your home sold. I would recommend her to everyone.
2021
Jim, a buyer from Greentown, PA
Sarah is knowledgeable about real estate in Pennsylvania. She has a good understanding of local requirements and laws. She was also helpful on property values and expectations. I found Sarah to be responsive and helpful with questions I had. She also provided good information regarding various trades to help with hone improvements. I highly recommend her.
2020
John kang , a buyer from Lakeville, PA
Sara did a great job and gave me quick answer whenever I ask something. She was professional and it was great working with her.
I got all information what I need from her .
Im happy she did for me , l would like to recommend her to everyone highly.

2021
Gtone, a buyer from Lake Ariel, PA
Sarah had my interest as top prority, and was honast from day one. When it came down to my strong offer, she got it done ASAP, no matter how late it got, she kept on working.
Thank you
2020
Robert, a seller from Hawley, PA
Sarah made everything easy for us.
2020
LKCompton, a seller from Hawley, PA
Sarah is the best real estate agent we have ever had the pleasure of doing business with. She truly is a friend on the inside that is working for you. We really appreciated her knowledge, honesty, integrity,professionalism and hard work ethics, making what could of been a stressful and difficult process flow smoothly and seamlessly. We have had a wonderful experience with Sarah and look forward to working with her in the future!
2020
Gonzalez, a buyer from Lords Valley, PA
Sarah was awesome, she has great knowledge of area and home purchasing process. Thanks to Sarah we are happy in our new home.
2020
Sash, a seller from Hawley, PA
Sarah is professional! She was informative and prompt during the whole process. Everything went smooth & I appreciate her time and effort. Sarah is a team player and great to work with!
2020