This agent has 49 reviews.


Dave Harner, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
Amy is a knowledgeable agent. Very professional. Great communication and keeping me up to date. I recommend Amy with no reservations. She also makes a great chocolate pie.

MARIA LOPEZ, a seller from Auburndale, FL
Amy was helpful thru the process of selling our home, always answering my calls and texts even after hours. Thank you !

KAREN SYKES, a seller from Auburndale, FL
Amy Reynolds stands above the rest in her dedication to the seller. She is attentive, respectful, an excellent listener, responsive, determined. She is an all around great lady. She knows what she is doing and puts that knowledge to good use in selling your home to your complete satisfaction. I wouldn't recommend anyone else!

Harry Naylor, a seller from Inwood, FL
THE BEST 111111111111111

TIM BAKER & ANN BAKER, a seller from Inwood, FL
Amy Reynolds did more than an exceptional process of selling our house. First day she jumped right in taking pics of our home, sign up and on the multiple listing sites. I felt so comfortable to ask questions. She always let us know after each showing how it went. Very professional. I trusted her and that was a blessing. I highly recommend Amy Reynolds to sell your house or commercial property. And besides who would make you a fresh delicious Chess Chocolate pie to give to you after closing. That's our sweet relator.

PETER & AMANDA OSBORNE, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
We have owned our home in Florida for many years. The time had come to make the emotional decision to sell and we could not have had a better realtor to support us through the process. Amy was professional, kind, understanding and went way above and beyond all expectation when it came to the selling of our home. We live in the UK so we had to do everything by phone e mail and messaging. We had complete trust in Amy and this was well founded. Amy ensured we understood everything that needed to happen and ensured we were able to complete the sale remotely only having to arrive in the USA to complete the final paperwork and clear our personal possessions from the house. Amy was able to help us with the disposal of the house contents and put us in touch with lovely families who could benefit from our furniture etc. We cannot thank Amy enough and wholly recommend her to and buyer or seller.

Anonymous, a buyer from Cypress Gardens, FL
Excellent job helping us to find just the right property, always being available, helpful, communicative, and knowledgeable about our area! Very pleased with the process from beginning to end! :)

Anonymous, a buyer from Alturas, FL
Amy has assisted my family with approx 11 homes being sold and bought, we do not trust anyone else with our properties.

Tim And Andrea, a buyer from Bartow, FL
Amy treated us like family. She kept our expressed home and neighborhood necessities on the forefront to align with our desired budget range. Her ability to respond and execute action with limited time was impeccable. We had worked with two realtors prior to Amy who were not able to sympathize with our situation in order for us to move swiftly. We called upon other members of our family (who live in Florida) to do in person, home walk-through and overall assessments since we reside several states away. Amy was completely accommodating to work with us in that capacity to ensure we did not miss out on housing opportunities due to our adverse distance logistics. Our only regret is that we did not work with Amy from the beginning of our journey.

DANIEL AND CHRISTIE DEAN, a seller from Cypress Gardens, FL
Amy did a great job selling our home. We were out of state when our home was sold and it couldn't have been handled any more professional then what it was. When we purchase a home in the area in the future we will definitely consider Amy as our realtor. It was a pleasure having her sell our home that we were in more then thirty years. Thanks again Amy!

Anonymous, a buyer from Winter Haven, FL
What a joy and blessings working with Mrs Amy, the knowledge of understanding the value of other properties in the surrounding area. Assisting you with what types of inspection maybe needed for your protection. Very beautiful, warm and caring spirit. She communicated with me though out the entire process and professional. An amazing journey and I'm so grateful to have shared it with you and I'm going that say it was part of the Master's plan. May you continue to be blessed for being a blessing to me and my home buying experience. Gail

Gwen Wilson, a buyer from Auburndale, FL
Amy was always available to assist when we wanted to see a home. She is professional, thoughtful snd patient.

Donald Gugel, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
Amy knows the local market and rental market well.

She shows up and does the hard work other do not. I have worked with many agents and she is the best in her area.

Thanks Amy for your hard work

Leo Dr LLC, a seller from Auburndale, FL
Amy supported us as manager for our property in Auburndale for nine years, she was attentive and available to help us as landlords and our tenants as well. Organizing repairs, keeping on tops of the multiple issues and the occasional 'challenging' situations that we all face in renting real estate. We have sold our units and the tenants were saddened to learn that she would no longer be managing the properties. We would recommend Amy to anyone looking for a property manager.

Chris Allison, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
Amy was efficient and was always available to speak whatever the time.
Good at updates and firstly knowledgeable.

Jeffrey Stabe, a buyer from Crooked Lake Park, FL
The process of purchasing your first home can be stressful and overwhelming. But, we were so lucky to have miss Amy! Amy took so much of the stress off of our shoulders. She was incredibly organized and punctual, every time we sent her a new house we were able to view it that day. Every time we went to look at a new house she was prepared with good insight into each house and answered every question we had. She treated us like family and helped us get into our first home!

Christine Jacobsen, a buyer from Winter Haven, FL
I had an excellent experience with Amy for my recent home purchase. She is friendly, professional, and knowledgeable about our area and the process. Everything was easy and went smoothly and quickly. Anytime I had questions or concerns she answered them promptly and made sure I was kept up to date with each step of the process. I highly recommend Amy for buying or selling a home!

Harry Naylor, a seller from Inwood, FL
I WOULD BE HAPPY TO REFER HER AS A REPUTABLE AND RELIABLE REALTOR

Anonymous, a seller from Cypress Gardens, FL
Amy is a resourceful, hard working, and professional full time realtor who gets results. Amy is knowledgeable of the local market and its trends. If you are buying or selling in Winter Haven, don't go anywhere else - just go to Amy Reynolds.

Chad Miller, a buyer from Cypress Gardens, FL
Amy was a fantastic agent. She gave us a good summary of the market and helped us price out house appropriately. We had an offer within two days!

Brandon Lutz, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
In this crazy market you would think anyone could sell your house and get you over asking. But after jumping into the process of selling our home, I quickly realized that we need a professional who knew their stuff. Amy was exactly that agent! She walked us through our double digit offer list, broke down the pros and cons of all the offers, and helped us land the best offer for us! Not only did we get a great offer, but she made it super easy for us to walk through this process. If you are in the greater Winter Haven area, I highly recommend you contact Amy!

Hayley Davis, a buyer from Auburndale, FL
Overall Amy was there to help me whenever needed; as first time home buyer it was a new experience but she was able to answer my questions and help me through this process.

Anonymous, a seller from Cypress Gardens, FL
Amy has served as our realtor three times over the past 10 years- helping us buy and sell homes! She is incredibly knowledgeable and provides exceptional customer service! We were on a tight timeline with our last move, and Amy worked diligently to ensure everything was on schedule and efficient. Amy thoughtfully guides her clients through the entire home buying process. She is highly skilled and passionate about her job! We recommend Amy to anyone buying or selling a home in Polk County!

Melissa Miller, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
Amy is easy to work with and is always kind and professional. She goes the extra mile for her clients and we highly recommend her!

Ashley Phillips, a seller from Lakeland Highlands, FL
Amy Reynolds was wonderful to work with when looking for our new home. We were looking for over 7 months, she was always patient and never made us feel rushed. When we finally found the home we were in love with she guided us on aspects that we were unfamiliar with at the time. Especially with the insane real estate market we have found ourselves in. She was always quick and responsive to everything that we came across. We highly recommend working her!

Amy Sherman, a seller from Jan Phyl Village, FL
Amy Reynolds helped us to sell our home for more than asking price. She is market knowledgeable, priced our house well and was flexible on the price. I was particularly appreciative of her rapid response to many questions I had about the process and steps. She was professional and scheduled many showings the first night and next day after listing our home. She sent us the 4 offers and explained each so we could get the best deal. Amy Reynolds was an awesome realtor.

Richard Stettler, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
Very knowledgeable of the market and how best to position our house, easy to communicate with and always sensitive to our concerns.
Best there is.

Anonymous, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
Amy is knowledgeable and gave us valuable input in getting our house ready for market that we would not have thought of. Kept us updated during the entire process. Will definitely use Amy for any future home purchases/sales.

Brittany Schley, a buyer from Cypress Gardens, FL
Working with Amy was the best experience! We will continue to use her expertise!

Judith Tanner, a buyer from Winter Haven, FL
Amy is professional and knows her stuff, yet she is friendly and genuinely nice. I really enjoyed working with her, and she knows how to make you feel at ease. She is honest and up-front. I like that.

Candace Hutchison, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
Amy was wonderful to work with, knowledgeable and kept us up to date on the entire process.

David Austin, a buyer from Lake Wales, FL
HAD ALL THE ANSWERS AND WHO WE NEEDED TO TALKED TO. WE LOVED WORKING WITH HER.

Tammie Lajoie, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
Amy has assisted my family many times over the years with selling and buying. She always maintains professionalism, courtesy and availability. Amy is always our first call for any Real Estate transactions.

Jackie Austin, a buyer from Lake Wales, FL
She found the property we wanted. Amy had all of the name of inspectors, insurance, locksmith and ect. She called or emailed us with any information we needed. Amy went out of her way many times to help us. She always paid attention to our request and was a wonder lady to work with.
David & Jacqueline Austin

Richard Lajoie, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
My wife and I live in New Hampshire makes it difficult for us to sell our condo, so, we contacted Amy and took the bull by the horn. Our listing was posted on a Thursday or Friday and sold on Monday. Amy took care of all arrangements and we just flow down to close. Extremely easy thanks to Amy. Our family has used talent for at least 5 times in the past with the same results.

Dale Keplinger, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
Amy is an incredible agent she did everything and more than I couldve imagined. Amy worked closely with us through the whole process and made everything and incredible experience

Csilla Lyerly, a seller from Auburndale, FL
As a fellow agent in Texas - my expectations were high when it came to getting my mom's place on the market quickly and SOLD. Amy was a great fit, she is professional, knowledgeable and communicated effectively. Very happy to have gotten multiple offers on the property within 12hrs of it being listed. Thank you for all your help.

Bill Wise, a buyer from Winter Haven, FL
Amy was all way there when any issue came up and was all way able to clear the issue up.
I really enjoy working with Amy.

Brenda Wise, a buyer from Winter Haven, FL
Amy was professional

Bob & Bonnie Fore, a buyer from Crooked Lake Park, FL
We would recomend Amy as our first choice.

Jonathan Eagin, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
Amy was a fantastic realtor for us twice! She helped us a find a house that met everything we needed and more. And then when job circumstances changed a year later and we had to move, she got our house on the market and sold quickly, all during the COVID-19 pandemic! We could not have asked for a better realtor.

Phyllis Page, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
Amy has become a good friend--she has been our realtor of choice and we really recommend her--she really knows her way around the real estate business! We highly recommend her. We are getting older and have issues remembering "things" but we can count on Amy to help us--always, and that means a great deal to both of us!!!! She does not act as our realtor but as a good friend too!!!

Eden Pruitt, a seller from Lake Wales, FL
Amy was knowledgeable and able to price our home well so that it sold quickly! She was professional at all of our encounters and most of all she was kind each time we had a question.

Joe Fiano, a buyer from Winter Haven, FL
I first met Amy when I was looking to purchase my first home. She was patient and showed me many homes until I found the right one. So when it was time to down size, Amy was my only choice. She knew exactly what I wanted and it didn't take long to find it. She helped me close on both properties on the same day. My wife and I truly love Amy as an agent and a person.

Monica Fox, a seller from Winter Haven, FL
Our house sold in 3 days by pictures taken by Amy Reynolds and posted on real estate markets available online. No showings. Buyer got a good deal on our house.

M. Garcia, a buyer from Winter Haven, FL
Amy is knowledgeable and answered any questions we had. She was flexible and always returned our calls in a timely matter. Amy really listened to what we really wanted in a house and was consistently searching on a daily basis. She would send us daily updates. We couldn't ask for a better realtor. It was a pleasure working with Amy and we would use her services again.

Charley Kilmer, a seller from Lake Alfred, FL
Amy Reynolds was accurate with the estimation of what mom's house was worth.
Of the three homes she has sold for us, her average selling time was one month.
There were never any surprises with dealing with her.
She knows what she is doing and goes the extra mile to satisfy her clients!

Chris Pruitt, a seller from Lake Wales, FL
Amy was to our house the day after we called and our house was online! She was in constant contact and got our house sold within a month!

Dawn Voisard, a buyer from Winter Haven, FL
This is the second purchase Amy has helped us with. Her thoroughness saved us from a major contract problem on our first purchase. The second purchase was completed in record time, which was a huge blessing to us as we needed the home by January 1st. She worked tirelessly to help us get it closed by December 30. I would highly recommend her!! She is a pleasure to work with.