This agent has 13 reviews.


Kristin & Joe, a seller from Islamorada, Village of Islands
Instead of continuing to rent in Islamorada we thought lets go look at some properties. We knew the location we wanted to be in & we needed 2 condos. One for me & my husband and one for my parents. Krissy was the listing agent. I called her on 1/29 at an odd hour expecting to leave a message. Instead we had a nice chat.
We toured 3 condos the next day, put offers in on 1/31 and closed on 3/15! Both condos, same building. Were all thrilled!

Krissy was stellar to work with. She was efficient, responsive and on top of every step in the process.
She is a wealth of knowledge not just as a RE Agent, but of the Keys as well.

We got to know her as more than just the RE Agent who facilitated our purchases.she is a truly lovely, kind and generous soul.

A whim phone call made a 40 year dream come true & a new friend we look forward to hanging out with in the years to come.


Philip Gallub, a seller from Islamorada, Village of Islands
Krissy is always available and on top of her game to keep the process moving forward and hung in there to sell our unit and at the same time find us another one. Both happened at the same time for closings which was an added bonus and as she says "it was meant to be"

Thank you

Pat Breitsch, a buyer from Tavernier, FL
My home purchase experience with Krissy Carnahan was top notch and so smooth and seamless throughout the process. Krissy kept me informed on availability of properties, was able to meet up at prospective properties without changing specific times, advised of information / procedures that I would not have been aware of without her knowledge, and informed when pricing was correct and if my offer was reasonable for a specific property. This was all done while she was talking care of her relative who was in and out of the hospital during my home search . You can tell Krissy loves people and loves her profession. I am 100 percent happy with how she handled my purchasing experience.

Debbie Orr, a seller from Monroe County, FL
Krissy was helpful explaining everything to me and had knowledge about property. She made it a great experience.

Liliu Peeez, a seller from Monroe County, FL
I highly recommend Krissy to anyone looking for an experienced, reliable, and knowledgeable Real Estate Agent. Krissy demonstrated her
experience and professionalism as a realtor at all times during the entire sales process of my house, which sold faster than I could imagine. I couldn't choose a better real estate agent to sell my property.

Anonymous, a seller from Islamorada, Village of Islands
I had known Krissy for 20 years before I asked her to sell my home. Partnering with her, I knew would be the right choice. Her communication skills were exceptional, always available and responsive with the information needed. Krissy's marketing skills got the extended exposure it needed to get it sold. When it came to negotiations, Krissy's expertise was a game-changer. Even he coordination in the closing and our move was beyond helpful ! What truly sets her apart is her positive attitude. It made a stressful process more enjoyable. Krissy is the ultimate friend and professional.

Steve Erckmann, a seller from Islamorada, Village of Islands
Very competent and thorough-pleasure to work with.

Anonymous, a buyer from Islamorada, Village of Islands
It started with a brief encounter in an open house, it went on to a conversation that led to, maybe one day I will buy something in the keys, to informing us all about the growth in the market to showing us 3 homes and less than a week later signed offer on our home. Krissy has been my confident, trust advisor and friend who help get this house close in less than 3 weeks. She knows everyone and makes sure her clients are well taken care off and kept informed to make knowledgable decisions. There is no pressure, she always says when I have doubts," you got to do what is right for you and your family"...We did, we took her advice, her guidance, her connections to the local area and we closed on our second home. Looking forward to moving in & continuing the friendship and she will be my go to Realtor, if ever I sell or want to buy again...Oh her Colleague Lisa Benze is another amazing professional. Thank you Krissy, St. Joseph was with us all!

Sally Dean, a seller from Islamorada, Village of Islands
Krissy handled all of our needs to get the sale done quickly and remote.
Kathryn Allen skillfully coordinated all the signatures and paperwork for the closing. Nice job everyone!

Christine Turner, a seller from Islamorada, Village of Islands
It was a pleasure working with Krissy Carnahan albeit remotely. She was available to answer questions quickly and decisively. I couldnt have been happier with her expeditious service. Thank you.

TOM & SUSAN JELINSKI, a buyer from Islamorada, Village of Islands
Krissy is one of the most professional realtors I have ever met. Every aspect of our realtor experience with her was perfect! Her market and financial knowledge made our purchase a pleasure from start through closing. We highly recommend her as your realtor of choice!

Brandt Rising, a seller from Islamorada, Village of Islands
Working with Krissy was a pleasure. She understood the difficult situation of working with 4 owners. She was responsive, knowledgeable, efficient, expeditious, hardworking, honest, and pleasant.
She has excellent people skills.
We engaged her services and closed the contract in less than a month.

Anonymous, a buyer from Islamorada, Village of Islands
Very pleasant working with her and she was instrumental in helping us decide on this unit. She was responsive and was able to provide all the information we needed to make an intelligent choice on our purchase. She work well between seller and buyer to make this happen