This agent has 70 reviews.


Larry Morgan, Valrico, FL, a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
Mary Caserta was exteremly helpful and knowledgeable about the entire process from listing to close. I would reccomend using Mary Caserta for your next home purchase or sale!

Qing Zeng, Yulee FL, a buyer from Yulee, FL
Mary is an exceptional real estate agent. Coming from out of the State, we needed a lot of hand-holding to navigate the market. She made a potentially stressful experience relexing and even fun. She was not only there for us with every detail of the purchasing process, but also went above and beyond to help us settle down into our new home. We leaned on her for almost everything. She is prefessional, knowlegeable, patient and kind. She is such a credit to your company.

Christine Hendrix, Fernandina Beach, Fl, a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
We attempted to sell this property by using a different broker/realtor. That broker/realtor has the property for about 9 months with no success. When we listed this property with Ms. Caserta, it was sold within 3 months. We greatly appreciate Ms. Caserta and would highly recommend her.

Christine Hendrix, Fernandina Beach, Fl, a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
Ms. Caserta was extremely easy to work with. She listened, offered professional advice and was available for consultation as needed. Ms. Caserta was sensitive to the needs of our family and the complex nature of this sale. We would highly recommend Ms. Caserta and will definitely use her in the future.

Melissa Italia, Yulee, FL, a buyer from Yulee, FL
As a client in my 20's, navigating my first home purchase was initially an overwhelming experience until I was referred to Mary Caserta by a family member that had the pleasure of working with her for their purchase. Mary sent me listings that fit my wants and needs within the hour. She not only negotiated on my behalf keeping me 20k under my budget, but she found me the land of my dreams in Yulee, FL I thought I would never be able to get my hands on. Her professionalism and availability made it 110% easier to get through all the hectic commotion of the inspections, and her transparency helped me to make the most of my closing. I even had the pleasure of working with her co-representative James Caserta, who was kind enough to accompany me for inspections and helped me put together a nail biting closing after my sellers were hospitalized on our closing day by getting us a mobile notary. Thank you for helping me get my 2 year old his dinosaur room. I am so so thankful for you both.

Roger Lucas, Decherd, TN, a seller from Jacksonville, FL
Overall in all aspects she was one of the best I have dealt with lately and did an amazing job with everything.

Jack & Cheryl Carfagno, Fernandina Fl, a buyer from Fernandina Beach, FL
Mary is the best!
My wife and I think of Mary not just as our realtor but as a close friend.
I would recommend Mary to my friends and family.

Mark Drummeter Greenbelt, Md, a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
I have known Mary for many years. She was my agent for the two properties I purchased in Fernandina Beach. She is incredibly knowledgeable, helpful, and easy to work with. I trust her completely to handle all aspects of buying or selling a property.

Paul Thornton , a buyer from Yulee, FL
See previous comments

Michael Ackerman, Fernandina Beach , a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
Once again, there's no one in Nassau County that knows real estate transactions like Mary and Jim Caserta. They are the Tina Turner's of real estate (hardest working). Both Century 21/Miller Elite and the Caserta's are highly rated at our house.
Michael and Ann Ackerman
904-753-0888

Gregory Nichols , a buyer from Fernandina Beach, FL
She was great to work with and helpful she went above and beyond to make sure that our needs were met

H. Sorrells , a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
Mary Caserta guided me through the selling of home, that was bitter sweet. She had my best interest in hand the whole time. I could not recommend anyone better to lead in the selling any home.

James F Jayo / Fernandna Beach FL, a buyer from Yulee, FL
I would definitely use Mary Caserta again in the future if needed!

James F Jayio, 97042 Woodsork, a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
I would recommend Mary Caserta to anyone selling their home.

Excellent experience with Mary. and Jim Caserta. they. went above the call of duty. Very.professional.

Colleen Hodge Fernandina Beach, FL, a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
Mary Caserta was a kind professional who always addressed our needs and concerns. She is an agent we would TOTALLY recommend and turn to again to sell or buy another property.

Again, I can not praise Mary Caserta enough. She always took our calls, answered our questions and researched any and all information. She work diligently to provide excellent service.

Sally Granda, Blue Ridge, GA, a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
Mary Caserta helped us buy our condo. When we decided to sell it, we knew we would ask Mary to help us again. She is professional, makes pertinent suggestions, provides helpful recommendations, and pays attention to details. She made us feel we were her only clients when we certainly knew that we were not! Mary purchased a needed part for the new dishwasher's installation so that said installation could be completed prior to closing.
As out-of-town sellers, Mary (as well as her husband Jim Caserta) kept my husband and me informed of progress toward closing and conveyed buyers' questions. We are so pleased with our experiences with Mary and appreciate her professionalism.

Shawn Tucker Fernandina Beach, FL, a seller from Yulee, FL
Mary was recommended to me by several people and I now understand why. we were in communication anytime of any day, even if she was out of town on vacation. One perspective buyer required extensive information from the county and she was an immense help with this. she was always a pleasure to deal with and talk to. I cant think of anything else that couldve been done to help sell this property.

Shirley C., a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
We have a great pleasure working with Mary and Jim. Their local knowledge and the patience have been wonderful.

Joe and Tammy Szewczyk , a buyer from Fernandina Beach, FL
Mary Caserta did a wonderful job helping us find a forever home on the island. She did a great job keeping us up to date since we were 14 hours away. Very knowledgeable of trustworthy people to make this process run smoothly.

Claudia and Stan Kavan, a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
MARY Caserta is the consummate realtor. Shes not only your realtor, shes your friendly guide and mentor to get your home sold. Shes available when needed to offer assistance and/or advice. It was a positive wonderful experience selling our home with MARY.

Chris Caserta, a buyer from Yulee, FL
My Brother and Sister in Law are the best!!!!!!!

Orit Guterbaum fertouk, Israel, a buyer from Fernandina Beach, FL
Being abroad, Mrs. Mary was our "eyes and ears" during all stages of the transaction. We felt we can trust her and were satisfied of how she dealt with all issues instead of us. She kept a close communication with us, including e-mails and phone calls, despite the chalenging time difference. She allowed us to feel that all is taken care of, and so it was. All was done in an impressive willingness, and in a agreeble, even friendly, manner.
We highly recommend her.

Joy and Sam, a seller from Yulee, FL
"Mary and Jim - Sam and I can't thank you guys enough for all the hard work, dedication and the time you spent in selling our home. You made it easy for us! Thank you for all of the hard work you both did for us, we much appreciate it. We most definitely will suggest you to anyone we know who is selling or wanting to purchase a home, you are experts in your field and we were lucky to have you as our Realtor and Broker both buying our house and selling it."

Jeff Lewis, Jacksonville, NC, a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
Jim and Mary exceeded our expectations. They are always available and respond quickly and professionally to keep the process moving forward. They have a great marketing strategy and we began to receive offers soon after listing. We were pleased with the final offer from the buyers and the closing process was seamless. I would recommend Jim and Mary and will use them again if buying or selling real estate in the area.

Laurie Merwarth Yulee, a seller from Yulee, FL
Having worked with Mary in the past I felt confident getting in touch with her again. Shes easy to work with and has always been easy to contact and work with buying or selling a home.

Leonard Nall Fernandina Beach, a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
I chose Mary because we had an excellent experience prior and for her honesty and market knowledge

Art Sanchez Yulee , a buyer from Yulee, FL
Thank you!
Everything went smoothly!

Marie Kehler Philippines , a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
Mary is the best..she and Jimmy work hand in hand to come up with ideas to ensure the sake of my house. Their strategy worked well for the situation I was in. My house sold at a price I was happy and just in time before my departure put of Florida. I gave used Mary and Jimmy on my previous house sale and they have always met my needs beyong expectation.
2018
Kim Tozzi Ft Lauderdale, Fl, a seller from Fernandina Beach, FL
Mary Caserta was great to work with! Always listening to our needs. She went above and beyond any realtor we have ever dealt with. We dont live in town and needed some repairs done. Mary found the best people to help us out! She is professional and so nice. Realtors of her caliber are really hard to find! I would highly recommend Mary Caserta.
2018