Phenomenal Home with private backyard oasis

Perfect Hamptons Alternative. Desirable cul-de-sac location with extraordinary nature ambiance and privacy, shy 1 acre professionally landscaped with numerous specimen trees, exterior lighting, rock walls, built-in charcoal BBQ, 20 x 40 lake style free form heated gunite pool with waterfall and diving rock recently re-marble dusted and updated propane heater, surrounded by bluestone patio. This distinguished home has been lovingly maintained by the original owners and has many custom details; hand painted accent walls, immaculate hardwood floors, built-ins, dual fireplace, surrund sound (inside & outside), etc. Exquisite architectural details, along with lots of large windows & skylights providing ample natural light. The 2nd floor is boasting an Enormous Primary Bedroom with double closet, walk-in closet, vanity area, vast bathroom with separate shower, double sinks, oversized jacuzzi tub.

3 additional bedrooms and a full bathroom with double sink complete the 2nd floor. There is also a 2nd primary bedroom option or guest bedroom with full bathroom or home office on the main level with an outside entrance. Main floor laundry room, eat-in-kitchen with marble floors, granite countertops, backsplash & center island, formal dining room, den & living room with dual fireplace, guest half bathroom. Full finished basement with expansive gym area, sitting area, utilities. 2 car attached garage with inside entrance. Huge Driveway, repaved, Cedar siding repainted, newer windows & roof, customized stone mailbox, basketball area, exceptional curb appeal. Close to Setauket Harbor, Hospitals, Elite #1 SUNY at Stony Brook, Main Street Restaurants & more, sought after Three Village School District. Experience the perfect blend of suburban tranquility and sophisticated living at 46 Caleb Brewster Road in Old Setauket . This residence is more than a home, it's a statement of elegance and comfort. Homeowner may be willing to sell partia lly furnished with some custom furniture & some gym equipment.

Request Information
on 46 Caleb Brewster Rd
in East Setauket, NY
Presented by Cheryl Constantine (Mulqueen) at
Locust Valley.


Property MLS #3565862 from OneKeyMLS

+ Reveal additional info including schools and tax history

+ Toggle All

+ Bedrooms

Bedrooms: 5

+ Other Rooms

Total Rooms: 11
Basement Features: Finished, Full
Basement Description: Finished, Full
Exercise Room: Yes

+ Bathrooms

Total Bathrooms: 4
Full Bathrooms: 3
1/2 Bathrooms: 1

+ Interior Features

First Floor Bedroom
Cathedral Ceiling(s)
Den/Family Room
Eat-in Kitchen
Exercise Room
Formal Dining
Entrance Foyer
Granite Counters
Guest Quarters
Master Bath
Pantry
Powder Room
Storage
Walk-In Closet(s)
Flooring: Hardwood, Wall To Wall Carpet
Window Features: Skylight(s)

+ Heating and Cooling

Cooling Features: Central Air
Fireplace Features: Wood Burning Stove
Heating Features: Oil, Hot Water
Number of Fireplaces: 1

+ Exterior and Lot Features

Private Entrance
Sprinkler System
Fencing: Back Yard, Fenced, Partial
Patio And Porch Features: Patio

+ Pool and Spa

Pool Features: In Ground
Pool Private: Yes

+ Garage and Parking

Attached Garage: Yes
Garage Spaces: 2
Parking Features: Private, Attached, 2 Car Attached, Driveway, Garage, Off Street, On Street

+ Land Info

Lot Description: Part Wooded, Cul-De-Sec, Private
Lot Size Acres: 0.9300046
Lot Size Square Feet: 40511

+ Home Features

View: Panoramic

+ Homeowners Association

Association: No
Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees: 0

+ School Information

Elementary School: Minnesauke Elementary School
Elementary School District: Three Village
High School: Ward Melville Senior High School
High School District: Three Village
Middle School: Paul J Gelinas Junior High School
Middle or Junior School District: Three Village
+ Display Complete School Details

Minnesauke Elementary School is a public elementary school located approximately 1.2 miles away.
Map directions

Ward Melville Senior High School is a public high school located approximately 1.6 miles away.
Map directions

Paul J Gelinas Junior High School is a public middle school located approximately 1.7 miles away.
Map directions

The Laurel Hill School is a private elementary and middle school located approximately 0.3 miles away.
Map directions

+ Other Property Info

Annual Tax Amount: 28603.07
Tax Block: 0005
Source Listing Status: Active
County: Suffolk
Cross Street: Gnarled Hollow
Directions: Main Street to Gnarled Hollow Road, left on Caleb Brewster Road to end of cul-de-sac, house is on the right just before the end - no for sale sign on lawn
List Price Low: 1049000
Source Property Type: Residential
Exclusions: Chandelier(s)
Parcel Number: 0200-134-00-05-00-009-000
Township: Brookhaven
Property Subtype: Single Family Residence
Source System Name: C2C
+ Reveal Tax History

Year	Assessments Building + Land Total	Tax
2023	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$28,252
2022	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$27,641
2021	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$27,391
2020	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$26,931
2018	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$26,175
2017	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$25,641
2016	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$25,264
2015	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$24,450
2014	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$23,575
2013	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$21,943
2012	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$21,252
2011	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$20,815
2010	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$19,855
2008	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$18,790
2007	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$17,838
2006	$6,345 + $525 $6,870	$16,879

+ Reveal Property Sale History

Listing removed 2024-07-16
$1,149,000
OneKeyMLS

---

Listed 2024-07-15
$1,149,000
OneKeyMLS

---

Price Changed 2024-07-14
$1,149,000
OneKeyMLS

---

Price Changed 2024-06-11
$1,179,000
OneKeyMLS

---

Listed 2024-05-30
$1,375,000
OneKeyMLS

---

Sold 1986-10-03
$343,000
Public Record

+ Building and Construction

Year Built: 1987
Common Walls: No Common Walls
Construction Materials: Frame, Cedar, Stone
Levels: Three Or More
Property Age: 37
Property Condition: Mint +++
Architectural Style: Colonial

+ Utilities

Sewer: Cesspool
Water Source: Public