As of 2024-05-20
There are currently no USDA loan eligible properties available in Fire Island
To find a home that may be eligible for a USDA loan, have a look at the neighboring city Laurel, NY.
Laurel is at least partially within a zone of USDA loan eligibility.

Available property information updates daily. Check back later for new active listings on the market.

USDAProperties.com

City Image

All Active Listings Near
Fire Island, New York in Suffolk County Local Realtors USDAProperties Agent Contact Page Fire_Island QR code
Postal Code: 11782

Sorted by Price $
Sort by $      
property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  26  
  share icon  
Listed by Glenn A. Rice at Brown Harris Stevens (Westhampton Beach)
$4,250,000

443 Sail Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  29  
  share icon  
Listed by Glenn Rice at Brown Harris Stevens W Hampton
$4,250,000

443 Sail Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  35  
  share icon  
Listed by Matthew Hughes at D Katen Fire Island Prop Ltd. Latest property estimate: $2,380,000
$3,500,000

418 Ocean Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

*New Listing*

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  17  
  share icon  
Listed by Mitchell Muroff at Muroff Hospitality Group
$3,250,000

22 Atlantic Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  35  
  share icon  
Listed by Nancy Martino at D Katen Fire Island Prop Ltd
$3,200,000

362 Ocean Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  5  
  share icon  
Listed by Samantha Densieski at D Katen Fire Island Prop Ltd. Latest property estimate: $2,932,400
$3,150,000

72 Bay Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  16  
  share icon  
Listed by Angelika Jamrozek at D Katen Fire Island Prop Ltd
$2,300,000

324 Sky Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  17  
  share icon  
Listed by Glenn Rice at Brown Harris Stevens W Hampton. Latest property estimate: $2,093,600
$2,250,000

617 Shore Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  27  
  share icon  
Listed by Glenn A. Rice at Brown Harris Stevens (Westhampton Beach)
$2,250,000

617 Shore Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  1  
  share icon  
Listed by Vincent Petrarca at Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island. Latest property estimate: $2,122,000
$2,200,000

491 Bay Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  7  
  share icon  
Listed by Angelika Jamrozek at D Katen Fire Island Prop Ltd. Latest property estimate: $1,196,800
$1,999,999

482 Tarpon Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

*New Listing*

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  15  
  share icon  
Listed by Vincent Petrarca at Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island. Latest property estimate: $1,847,800
$1,995,000

490 Bay Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  7  
  share icon  
Listed by Vincent Petrarca at Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island. Latest property estimate: $1,135,900
$1,990,000

404 Ocean Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

*New Construction*

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  16  
  share icon  
Listed by Mitchell Muroff at Muroff Hospitality Group
$1,795,000

21 Lewis Walk
Cherry Grove, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  36  
  share icon  
Listed by John Forte at D Katen Fire Island Prop Ltd. Latest property estimate: $1,197,100
$1,679,000

267 Floral Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  2  
  share icon  
Listed by Vincent Petrarca at Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island. Latest property estimate: $787,900
$1,675,000

388 Neptune Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

*New Listing*

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  22  
  share icon  
Listed by Doreen Katen at D Katen Fire Island Prop Ltd
$1,650,000

293 Bay Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  10+ Virtual Tour  
  share icon  
Listed by Vincent Petrarca at Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island
$1,625,000

597 Cottage Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  13  
  share icon  
Listed by Vincent Petrarca at Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island. Latest property estimate: $1,491,200
$1,600,000

297 Fire Island Blvd
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  19  
  share icon  
Listed by John Forte at D Katen Fire Island Prop Ltd
$1,575,000

514 E Fire Island Blvd
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  share icon  
Listed by Vincent Petrarca at Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island. Latest property estimate: $1,404,800
$1,500,000

309 Shady Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  33+ Virtual Tour  
  share icon  
Listed by Cynthia Manzolillo at Signature Premier Properties. Latest property estimate: $1,362,300
$1,450,888

478 Tarpon Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  35  
  share icon  
Listed by Kevin Loiacono at BrookHampton Realty. Latest property estimate: $1,354,400
$1,450,000

8 Anita Dr
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  5  
  share icon  
Listed by Vincent Petrarca at Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island. Latest property estimate: $1,265,800
$1,300,000

154 Ocean Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  35  
  share icon  
Listed by Joanne Sturchio at Sayville. Latest property estimate: $1,224,200
$1,250,000

48 Kemi Ln
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  36  
  share icon  
Listed by Joanne Sturchio at Sayville. Latest property estimate: $1,186,700
$1,200,000

7 Winmar Ln
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  23+ Virtual Tour  
  share icon  
Listed by Cynthia Manzolillo at Signature Premier Properties. Latest property estimate: $1,117,400
$1,188,936

292 Bay Walk
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  36  
  share icon  
Listed by Joanne Sturchio at Sayville. Latest property estimate: $1,069,100
$1,100,000

124 Colton Ave
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  27  
  share icon  
Listed by Jocelyn Agosto at Keller Williams Realty Elite
$1,100,000

6 Bohack Ct
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  10  
  share icon  
Listed by Allison Grosse at Howard Hanna Coach Realtors - East Islip. Latest property estimate: $1,042,500
$1,100,000

48-52 Browns River Rd
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  25  
  share icon  
Listed by Stephanie Reinertsen at Breezes Brokerage Llc. Latest property estimate: $1,060,200
$999,999

7 Hudson Ave
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  8  
  share icon  
Listed by James Manikas at Realty Connect Usa L I Inc
$999,990

26 Swayze St
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  36  
  share icon  
Listed by Giovanni Distefano at Sayville. Latest property estimate: $796,400
$998,000

65 Macon Ave
Sayville, NY

*New Construction*

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  13  
  share icon  
Listed by Evelyn Danko at Summer Place Realty
$998,000

260 East Walk
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  13  
  share icon  
Listed by Evelyn Danko at Summer Place Realty
$965,000

85 Gerard Walk
Cherry Grove, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  10  
  share icon  
Listed by Evelyn Danko at Summer Place Realty. Latest property estimate: $663,600
$950,000

99 Greene Walk
Cherry Grove, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  19  
  share icon  
Listed by Evelyn Danko at Summer Place Realty
$899,000

63 Aeon Walk
Sayville, NY

*New Listing*

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  30  
  share icon  
Listed by Joanne Sturchio at Sayville. Latest property estimate: $858,700
$895,000

15 Timber Ridge Ct
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  27  
  share icon  
Listed by Virginia Cunningham at Sayville. Latest property estimate: $845,700
$859,000

10 Puritan Rd
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  15  
  share icon  
Listed by Thomas Droscoski at Go Asset Inc
$849,000

25 Fire Island Blvd
Fire Island Pines, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  10  
  share icon  
Listed by Evelyn Danko at Summer Place Realty
$825,000

124 Duryea Walk
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  22  
  share icon  
Listed by Lee Cillo at Shine Realty Group. Latest property estimate: $668,100
$799,000

305 Sunrise Dr
Sayville, NY

*New Listing*

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  36  
  share icon  
Listed by Caitlin Shelton at Realty Connect USA L I Inc. Latest property estimate: $566,600
$799,000

250 Johnson Ave
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  28+ Virtual Tour  
  share icon  
Listed by Frank Mann at Berkshire Hathaway. Latest property estimate: $829,200
$799,000

112 Elm St
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  14  
  share icon  
Listed by Evelyn Danko at Summer Place Realty
$795,000

59 Aeon Walk
Cherry Grove, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  30  
  share icon  
Listed by Richard Bitzer at H & G Realty New York. Latest property estimate: $593,400
$788,000

23 Pearl Ct
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  32  
  share icon  
Listed by Jose Padro at Signature Premier Properties. Latest property estimate: $549,300
$774,999

703 Chester Rd
Sayville, NY

*New Listing*

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  36  
  share icon  
Listed by Sean Manning at Signature Premier Properties. Latest property estimate: $714,500
$749,000

27 Pine St
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  31  
  share icon  
Listed by Jimmy Amram at Long Beach. Latest property estimate: $610,700
$739,000

42 Regina Dr
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  14+ Virtual Tour  
  share icon  
Listed by Robert Ponzi at Century 21 KR Realty. Latest property estimate: $623,300
$729,000

9 Marcia Pl
Sayville, NY

*New Listing*

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  31  
  share icon  
Listed by Jason Kaiser at Fortune Realty of LI Inc. Latest property estimate: $701,900
$718,000

15 Claire Ln
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  19  
  share icon  
Listed by Mildred Thomas at Signature Premier Properties. Latest property estimate: $683,400
$699,000

134 Marion St
Sayville, NY

*New Listing*

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  18  
  share icon  
Listed by Lisa Fasano at Compass Greater NY LLC. Latest property estimate: $713,600
$695,000

86 Foster Ave
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  27  
  share icon  
Listed by Margaret Nenos at Realty Connect USA L I Inc. Latest property estimate: $575,200
$669,990

52 Regina Dr
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  23  
  share icon  
Listed by Jacqueline Nett at Sayville. Latest property estimate: $609,800
$639,000

14 Elaine Dr
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  15  
  share icon  
Listed by Barbara Adamo at Medallion Properties Inc. Latest property estimate: $640,300
$629,000

46 John St
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  25+ Virtual Tour  
  share icon  
Listed by Debora Kaminski at Signature Premier Properties. Latest property estimate: $562,600
$599,990

54 Potomac Ln
Sayville, NY

*New Listing*

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  21  
  share icon  
Listed by Daniel Byrne at Fresh Start Properties Llc. Latest property estimate: $559,100
$599,000

3 Belinda Ct
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  3  
  share icon  
Listed by Robin Citriniti at Netter Real Estate Inc
$599,000

54A Lewis Walk
Cherry Grove, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  19  
  share icon  
Listed by Gail Carillo at Coldwell Banker American Homes. Latest property estimate: $554,200
$549,990

628 Durham Rd
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  25  
  share icon  
Listed by Julie Poidomani at Realty Connect USA L I Inc. Latest property estimate: $528,000
$549,000

51 Brook St
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  1  
  share icon  
Listed by Kimberly Cammarata at Westhampton Beach. Latest property estimate: $575,300
$500,000

27 Claire Ln
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  16  
  share icon  
Listed by Christine Wright at Shine Realty Group. Latest property estimate: $454,800
$499,000

12 Revere Dr Unit 12
Sayville, NY

*New Listing*

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  14  
  share icon  
Listed by John Giacobbe at Hampton Estates Realty LLC. Latest property estimate: $487,700
$499,000

218 McNeil St
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  18  
  share icon  
Listed by Jake Guadagno at Serhant LLC. Latest property estimate: $421,700
$489,999

42 Revere Dr
Sayville, NY

*New Listing*

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  24  
  share icon  
Listed by Lisa Hendrickson at Sayville. Latest property estimate: $444,400
$459,000

102 Revere Dr Unit 102
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  14  
  share icon  
Listed by Lynn Deeg at Coldwell Banker American Homes. Latest property estimate: $459,500
$450,000

461 Lincoln Ave
Sayville, NY

property photo
  Ⓧ USDA  
  14  
  share icon  
Listed by Shannon Mullaney at Sayville
$324,000

328 Lakeland Ave Apt 1F
Sayville, NY

*New Listing*

Default City Image for Fire_Island