Gardiner, New York is a town with many attractive features, but there are also some potential disadvantages to consider when buying property there. Here are some of the advantages and disadvantages to keep in mind:

Advantages:
- Natural beauty: Gardiner is known for its beautiful natural surroundings, including the Shawangunk Ridge and the Wallkill River. This can be a major draw for outdoor enthusiasts and those looking for a peaceful retreat.

- Proximity to New York City: Gardiner is relatively close to New York City, making it a popular choice for people looking to escape the city for the weekend or move to a quieter location without being too far from the city's amenities.

- Historic charm: Gardiner is home to several historic sites, including the Gardiner Historic District and the Gardiner Rail Trail, which can be a draw for history buffs and those interested in preserving the town's past.

Disadvantages:
- Limited job opportunities: Gardiner is a small town with limited job opportunities, which can make it difficult for some residents to find work. This may be less of a concern for retirees or those who are able to work remotely.

- High property taxes: Property taxes in Gardiner can be relatively high, which may make it less affordable for some buyers. However, this can be offset by the town's relatively low housing prices, depending on the individual's financial situation.

- Limited amenities: While Gardiner has some basic amenities like grocery stores and restaurants, it may not have as many options as larger towns or cities. This may be a consideration for those who are used to having more choices available to them.

Overall, whether or not Gardiner is a good place to buy property depends on the individual's specific needs and preferences. It can be a great choice for those looking for natural beauty and historic charm, but may not be the best choice for those looking for a bustling city or a wide range of job opportunities.