*** No USDA eligible properties were found in Montauk Beach ***
To find a home that may be eligible for a USDA loan, have a look at the neighboring city Shelter Island Heights, NY. This city falls within a zone of USDA loan eligibility.

All Active Listings Near
City Image
Montauk Beach, New York in Suffolk County


Use the map and table links below to access listing details.
Red areas indicate USDA defined loan exclusion zones.
Official State Seal
100 active listings near Montauk Beach
👍 USDA, * Price Change, * New, * Sale Pending
$79,995,000    165 Surfside Dr
$36,950,000    42 and 44 Deforest Rd
$36,295,000    18 and 22 Maple St
$24,500,000    42 Deforest Rd
$19,950,000    40 Deforest Rd
$19,500,000    18 Maple St
$16,975,000    22 Maple St
$14,995,000    283 Old Montauk Hwy
$12,950,000    44 Deforest Rd
$12,950,000    44 Deforest Rd
$10,990,000    131 137 South Edgemere St
$9,950,000   * 335 E Lake Dr
$9,500,000    16 and 18 Wills Point Rd
$9,350,000    411 W Lake Dr
$8,895,000   * 24 Hamilton Dr
$8,195,000    16 Wills Point Rd
$8,000,000    21 S Euclid Ave
$7,995,000   * 36 Homeward Ln
$6,295,000    4 S Elmwood Ave
$5,500,000   * 36 Ditch Plains Rd
$5,500,000    101 Startop Dr
$5,495,000    17 Tara Rd
$4,995,000   * 92 Old West Lake Dr
$4,499,000    18 N Shore Rd
$4,495,000    131 S Edgemere St
$3,995,000    53 Kettle Hole Rd
$3,975,000    37 Houston Dr
$3,900,000    19 S Duncan Drdubois Dr and 25 S Duncan Dr
$3,850,000    18 N Shore Rd
$3,500,000    100 Deforest Rd
$3,400,000   * 46 N Shore Rd
$3,200,000    100 Deforest Rd
$3,200,000    100 Deforest Rd Unit 305
$3,100,000    63 Dogwood St
$3,100,000    63 Dogwood St
$2,995,000    41 Gilbert Rd
$2,995,000    45 S Euclid Ave
$2,795,000    40 Ditch Plains Rd
$2,795,000    40 Ditch Plains Rd
$2,750,000    19 S Dubois Dr
$2,750,000    19 S Dubois Dr
$2,650,000    45 Flamingo Rd
$2,575,000    117 S Forest St
$2,350,000   * 18 Fernald Rd
$2,300,000    23 Adams Dr
$2,300,000    49 Benson Dr
$2,250,000    45 Gannet Dr
$2,199,000   * 142 S Fairview Ave
$2,195,000    43 Caswell Rd
$2,195,000    43 Caswell Rd
$1,950,000    205 Fairview Ave
$1,950,000    126 Fairview Ave
$1,950,000    20 Foxboro Rd
$1,900,000    83 Surfside Ave
$1,795,000    54 E Lake Dr
$1,750,000    15 S Forest St
$1,750,000    15 S Forest St
$1,700,000    68 S Elmwood Ave
$1,650,000    157 Greenwich St
$1,650,000    157 Greenwich St
$1,650,000    99 Bryan Rd
$1,595,000    21 S Fulton St Unit 18
$1,595,000    21 S Fulton St Unit 18
$1,500,000    86 Laurel Dr
$1,495,000    12 Furness Rd
$1,395,000    43 Second House Rd
$1,395,000   * 97 Duryea Ave
$1,295,000    19 Ranch Ct
$1,195,000    94 Laurel Dr
$1,195,000   * 29 Fairway Pl
$1,100,000    6-8 S Faun
$975,000   * 38 Glenmore Ave
$925,000   * 55 S Euclid Ave Unit 6C
$895,000    100 Deforest Rd Unit 319
$799,000    236 Edgemere St Unit 431
$795,000    100 Deforest Rd Unit 514
$795,000    6 Soundview Dr # 7
$750,000    100 Deforest Rd Unit 513
$659,000    126 S Emerson Ave Unit 46
$625,000   * 707 Old Montauk Hwy Unit C16
$550,000    236 Edgemere St Apt 213
$539,000    727 Old Montauk Hwy Unit 401
$535,000    727 Old Montauk Hwy Unit 435
$529,000    236 Edgemere St Apt 411
$520,000   * 727 Old Montauk Hwy Unit 301
$515,000    727 Montauk Hwy Unit 403
$515,000    131 S Emerson Ave N Unit 238
$510,000    727 Old Montauk Hwy Unit 213
$505,000    727 Old Montauk Hwy
$500,000    727 Old Montauk Hwy Unit 224
$499,000    131 S Emerson Ave Unit 235
$465,000    236 Edgemere St
$449,000    236 Edgemere St Unit 428
$425,000    236 Edgemere St Unit 329
$350,000   * 327 Fairview Ave