Warning: 100% of this postal code is ineligible for rural development USDA home loans. Click for more details on 11963.
 

View more realtors helping home buyers in Shelter Island
City Logo

Patrick Mclaughlin
Agent Photo

The Experience You Need | The Results You Deserve
Patrick McLaughlin is a dedicated, results-driven real estate specialist whose love for the Hamptons community is second to ... see full details and contact information for Patrick ... enjoys playing tennis and occasionally jumps in the pool for a few laps.
Patrick has 15 recent and active property listings that range in price from $1,999,000 to $11,950,000 with the most recent sale on 2024-06-24 for $5,950,000.
Serving the areas of Sag Harbor, Wainscott, Sagaponack, East Hampton, Bridgehampton, Bellport, Shelter Island Heights, Southampton & Amagansett
Katherine O'Connell
Agent Photo
Born and raised in Southampton, Katherine has an in-depth knowledge of the Hamptons combined with an acute eye for what ... see full details and contact information for Katherine ... to make the home buying and selling experience as stress free as possible.
This realtor has 1 active or recent property listings for $689,000.
Serving the areas of Westhampton, Speonk, Eastport, Hampton Bays, Bridgehampton, Quogue, Water Mill, Amagansett, East Hampton & Sag Harbor
Kathleen M. Travers
Agent Photo

North Fork Real Estate Marketing Specialist.
Shes living the good life the North Fork life! Since her days as a summer kid in Southold, Kathleen always knew shed live ... see full details and contact information for Kathleen ... wit. 28 years in global marketing, advertising, and public relations.
Kathleen has 2 recent and active property listings that range in price from $764,500 to $1,150,000 with the most recent sale on 2022-05-16 for $610,000.
Serving the areas of Holtsville, Oakdale, Greenlawn, Brookhaven, Sayville, Eastport, Medford, Water Mill, East Quogue & East Moriches
Kevin Boone
Agent Photo

More Than Just About Real Estate, Its About A Lifestyle!
My name is Kevin D.Boone, I have been in the business of real estate ever since 2008. Reason why I ventured into real ... see full details and contact information for Kevin ... needs. I can be reached at 516-281-6059, looking for to meeting with you.
Kevin has 3 recent and active property listings that range in price from $600,000 to $730,000 with the most recent sale on 2024-05-07 for $635,000.
Serving the areas of Ridgewood, Rockville Centre, Southampton, Hampton Bays, East Meadow, Syosset & Hempstead
Read the reviews for Kevin Boone
Bonnie Kelly
Agent Photo

Committed to Excellence and Quality Service!
I love working at Wright Bros. RE, one of the most prestigious and professional offices in Rockland County. As a Licensed ... see full details and contact information for Bonnie ... and when I can assist my sellers through a smooth sale of their property.
Bonnie has 1 active or recent property listings for $549,000 with the most recent sale on 2024-03-06 for $1,325,000.
Serving the areas of Suffern, New City, Stony Point, Tappan, West Haverstraw, Tallman, West Nyack & Piermont
Samantha Zambrzycki
Agent Photo

I will help you MOVE in the right direction!
Signature Premier Properties


Office address:
4949 Express Dr N. STE 104
Ronkonkoma , NY

This realtor has 0 active or recent property listings for $0 with the most recent sale on 2024-06-20 for $620,000.
Serving the areas of Medford, Commack, Westhampton, Northport, Copiague, Centereach, Sag Harbor, East Moriches, Babylon & Riverhead
Margaret Brodis
Agent Photo

Douglas Elliman Real Estate


Office address:
28200 Main Rd
Cutchogue, NY

Margaret has 3 recent and active property listings that range in price from $745,000 to $1,575,000 with the most recent sale on 2024-04-09 for $1,300,000.
Serving the areas of Southold, Bellmore, East Marion, Shelter Island Heights, Bridgehampton, Orient, East Quogue, Remsenburg, Hampton Bays & New Suffolk
Carol Szynaka
Agent Photo

Look Back, Move Forward
Carol Szynaka, Licensed Associate Broker at Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty. With an impressive career spanning ... see full details and contact information for ... impact in the real estate landscape in the upcoming year and beyond.
Carol Szynaka has 4 recent and active property listings that range in price from $1,400,000 to $7,750,000 with the most recent sale on 2024-05-23 for $3,375,000.
Serving the areas of Sag Harbor, Cutchogue, Shelter Island, Orient, Peconic, Laurel, Southold & North Haven
Sianei Parker
Agent Photo

Let Me Find Your Next Spot To Homeownership.
Sianei Parker is an expert in market trends and comparable sales, including Nassau and Suffolk Counties. Her expertise is ... see full details and contact information for Sianei ... to a larger house, Sianei Parker is here to help you reach your goal.
This realtor has 0 active or recent property listings for $0 with the most recent sale on 2024-06-18 for $775,000.
Serving the areas of Southampton, Westhampton, Roslyn, Moriches, Westhampton Beach, East Northport, Quogue & Mill Neck
Danielle Golan
Agent Photo
When buying and selling your home, you are in good hands with Danielle. She will be your strongest advocate, your master ... see full details and contact information for Danielle ... your trusted confidant through one of the biggest choices of your life.
This realtor has 3 recent and active property listings that range in price from $425,000 to $600,000 with the most recent sale on 2024-05-08 for $2,300,000.
Serving the areas of Amagansett, Riverhead, Hampton Bays, Cutchogue, Ridge, Wading River, East Hampton, Montauk, Wainscott & Calverton
Lynne Leahy
Agent Photo

Professional Real Estate Agent
Meet Lynne Leahy AKA the Matchmaker of Hamptons real estate. Whether youre looking for your one true dream home or waiting ... see full details and contact information for Lynne ... not just finding a house; youre finding a place that feels like home.
This realtor has 2 recent and active property listings that range in price from $1,150,000 to $2,995,000 with the most recent sale on 2024-05-29 for $1,795,000.
Serving the areas of East Quogue, Westhampton Beach, Amagansett, Sag Harbor, Quogue, Bridgehampton, Westhampton & Southampton
Nicole Chimento
Agent Photo

Listen, Plan & Deliver
I am a licensed real estate salesperson with the Smithtown Coldwell Banker American Homes office. With a history of ... see full details and contact information for Nicole ... a call today to find out how I can help you purchase or sell a property!
This realtor has 2 recent and active property listings that range in price from $549,999 to $749,999 with the most recent sale on 2023-01-19 for $685,000.
Serving the areas of Bay Shore, Amagansett, Smithtown, Great River, Bethpage, Farmingville, Mattituck, Sag Harbor, Hauppauge & West Islip
Read the reviews for Nicole Chimento
Dianne Kay
Agent Photo

THE RIGHT AGENT IS KEY TO YOUR DREAM HOME
Dianne Kay's long-standing career as a real estate Associate Broker, starting in April 2000, showcases her dedication and ... see full details and contact information for Dianne ... anyone in the Long Island area looking to navigate the real estate market.
Dianne has 4 recent and active property listings that range in price from $199,000 to $895,000 with the most recent sale on 2023-03-28 for $700,000.
Serving the areas of Kings Park, Old Westbury, Bohemia, Seaford, Merrick, Lawrence, Wantagh, Bayville, North Babylon & East Northport
Susan C. Cincotta Real Estate Broker
Agent Photo

Welcome to Shelter Island
Susan C Cincotta, CBR, RSSR Real Estate Broker East End 2nd Place LIBOR Top Producer 2013 Office Listing Leader, 1st place ... see full details and contact information for Susan ... Players. She is an active Church & Community Volunteer in various roles.
Susan has 0 active or recent property listings for $0 with the most recent sale on 2024-06-13 for $2,825,000.
Serving the areas of Bridgehampton, Southampton, Montauk, Sagaponack, Shelter Island Heights, Greenport, Orient, Shelter Island, East Hampton & Cutchogue
Read the reviews for Susan C. Cincotta Real Estate Broker
Orit Ofir
Agent Photo
With more than 30 years as an accomplished leading real estate expert Orit Ofir exceeds expectations, connecting buyers and ... see full details and contact information for Orit ... friends on Long Island, entertaining at home and exploring fine wines.
This realtor has 1 active or recent property listings for $2,129,998 with the most recent sale on 2023-06-01 for $3,400,000.
Serving the areas of Sag Harbor, Southampton & Great Neck
Patrick Mccooey
Agent Photo

Your real estate is our business.
After a long and successful career on Wall Street, Patrick followed his true passion in life: Real Estate. He has been ... see full details and contact information for Patrick ... perfect person to represent you in all of your Real Estate transactions.
Patrick has 3 recent and active property listings that range in price from $779,000 to $4,999,000 with the most recent sale on 2024-06-12 for $2,300,000.
Serving the areas of Locust Valley, Mineola, Sag Harbor, New Hyde Park, West Hempstead, East Hampton, Westhampton, Old Westbury, Amagansett & Great Neck
Lisa Cea
Agent Photo

Cea at the closing!
Lisa Cea brings more than 20 years of banking experience to her work as a licensed Agent at Douglas Elliman. Her previous ... see full details and contact information for Lisa ... in your area and get the information you need. The next move is yours.
This realtor has 5 recent and active property listings that range in price from $420,000 to $1,200,000 with the most recent sale on 2024-04-23 for $1,850,000.
Serving the areas of Hampton, Water Mill, Hampton, Hampton, Holbrook, Wainscott, Hampton, Hampton, Holbrook & Hampton
Read the reviews for Lisa Cea
Denice Mussillo
Agent Photo
I believe that every home seller or buyer should be confident in any transaction.
This realtor has 1 active or recent property listings for $425,000 with the most recent sale on 2024-06-11 for $699,000.
Serving the areas of North Babylon, West Sayville, Huntington, Old Bethpage, Point Lookout, Copiague, Lindenhurst, West Babylon, Levittown & Roslyn
Read the reviews for Denice Mussillo
Latoya Naughton
Agent Photo

ListwithLaToya - Your Real Estate Needs, top of my list!
Born and raised in Brooklyn, NY, LaToya's dream of homeownership became a reality when she moved to Long Island over 10 ... see full details and contact information for Latoya ... time working on youth & community development initiatives through sports.
This realtor has 1 active or recent property listings for $1,400,000 with the most recent sale on 2023-12-28 for $575,000.
Serving the areas of Greenlawn, Hewlett, Farmingdale, Jericho, Long Beach, Point Lookout, East Northport & Water Mill
Donnetta Cumberbatch
Agent Photo

"Everyone Deserves the Gift of Home"
As a Realtor, my first priority is to make my clients happy. I listen to my clients wants and needs to achieve the best ... see full details and contact information for Donnetta ... buying or selling process is fun, and stress-free from start to finish.
This realtor has 1 active or recent property listings for $275,000 with the most recent sale on 2023-06-30 for $505,000.
Serving the areas of Cold Spring Harbor, Ridge, Oceanside, Amagansett, Sag Harbor, Hewlett, Center Moriches, Roslyn Heights & Great River
Not finding the person you are looking for? Search for a realtor by name.
 

See more agents working in Shelter Island 

Official State Seal

Shelter Island is a beautiful place to live with many advantages, but there are also some potential disadvantages to consider when buying property in the village.

Advantages:
- Stunning natural surroundings: Shelter Island is surrounded by both the Peconic Bay and the Atlantic Ocean, and is filled with lush greenery, forests and nature preserves. It's an ideal location for outdoor enthusiasts to enjoy swimming, hiking, biking, boating, and fishing excursions, among other activities.
- High quality of life: The community in Shelter Island is small, tight-knit, and very welcoming. The village has excellent schools, top rated healthcare facilities, and a low crime rate. Plus it is only a 20-minute ferry ride away from the Hamptons!
- Solid long-term investment: Shelter Island's real estate market is generally stable, with a high level of demand due to its prime location and incredible natural beauty. Owning property here is considered a good long-term investment, especially for those who are looking for a vacation property option.

Disadvantages:
- High Cost: Shelter Island is not affordable with the cost of living and property prices far higher than the national average. It is not uncommon to have million dollar price tags for real estate properties in Shelter Island.
- Limited Job Opportunities: Shelter Island is a small community with limited job opportunities, making it unsuitable for those who are seeking a more expansive career network or job market.
- Isolation: Shelter Island is an isolated place that can only be reached by ferry or private boat. Although this can offer tremendous privacy and solitude to those seeking a retreat or a retirement community, it can also become restrictive with accessible options limited during the off-season.