*** No USDA eligible properties were found in Shelter Island Heights ***
To find a home that may be eligible for a USDA loan, have a look at the neighboring city Greenport, NY. This city falls within a zone of USDA loan eligibility.
All Active Listings Near
City Image
Shelter Island Heights, New York in Suffolk County
Use the map and table links below to access listing details.
Red areas indicate USDA defined loan exclusion zones.
Official State Seal
8 active listings near Shelter Island Heights
👍 USDA, * Price Change, * New, * Sale Pending
$5,450,000    20 Prospect Ave
$3,750,000    4 Bayview Ave
$3,250,000    10 Serpentine Dr
$2,995,000    3 Bevan Pl
$1,080,000    9 W Neck Rd
$1,050,000    9 W Neck Rd
$875,000    39 Gardiners Bay Dr

Interested in fun facts and the history of Shelter Island Heights, NY?
Then read on!

Here are a few facts about the village of Shelter Island Heights, New York:

1. Shelter Island Heights is a small village located on Shelter Island, situated between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York.

2. The village was founded in the late 19th century as a Methodist summer retreat and still retains many of its historic Victorian-era homes and buildings.

3. It is home to the Shelter Island Heights Beach Club, which offers access to a private beach and swimming pool for members.

4. The village has a number of shops, restaurants, and historic landmarks, including the Shelter Island Heights Pharmacy and the Union Chapel, which hosts Sunday services and community events.

5. Shelter Island Heights is a popular vacation destination, known for its peaceful and picturesque surroundings, as well as its proximity to other popular Long Island destinations like the Hamptons and Montauk.