Welcome to 2125 Oak Orchard River Road!

Without a doubt this is on of the most unique waterfront properties to ever be offered for sale. Not is it a tremendous place to call home, it is an awesome income producing property. Many years ago, the 4 or 5 bedroom, 2 bath, 3600sqft main home was a gristmill and was moved to it's current location. There is still a working grain elevator! The home has also been used as the Kenyonville General store in the past. Also on this excellent property are 3 fishermans' lake side cottages. Each cottage sleeps at least 6 people, has a full kitchen, bath, living room, dining area and furnace. The cottages are almost constantly rented out on a per man / per night basis. The 1st class salmon and trout fishing and these cottages attract fisherman from across the country and even other countries!

There are also 2 full RV sites w/ hook-ups. This truly is an amazing opportunity to own a historic home and lake front rentals!

Request Information
on 2125 Oak Orchard River Rd
in Carlton, NY
Presented by Mark Swanson at
Patriot Real Estate Professionals.


Property MLS #R1518146 from NYStateAlliance

+ Reveal additional info including schools and tax history

+ Toggle All

+ Bedrooms

Bedrooms: 5
Bedrooms On Main Level: 1

+ Other Rooms

Total Rooms: 10
Basement Description: Full, WalkOutAccess, SumpPump

+ Bathrooms

Total Bathrooms: 2
Full Bathrooms: 2
Bathrooms On Main Level: 1

+ Interior Features

BreakfastBar
CeilingFans
SeparateFormalLivingRoom
HomeOffice
CountryKitchen
SlidingGlassDoors
NaturalWoodwork
BedroomonMainLevel
ProgrammableThermostat
Workshop
Door Features: SlidingDoors
Flooring: Carpet, Hardwood, Varies
Window Features: ThermalWindows

+ Appliances

Dryer
ElectricWaterHeater
GasOven
GasRange
Refrigerator
Washer
Laundry Features: MainLevel

+ Heating and Cooling

Heating Features: Electric, Propane, Oil, ForcedAir
Heating: Yes
Number of Fireplaces: 1

+ Waterfront and Water Access

Water Body Name: Lake Alice
BeachAccess
DockAccess
Lake

+ Exterior and Lot Features

Deck
Dock
GravelDriveway
Patio
Frontage Length: 232
Other Structures: Barns, Outbuilding, PoultryCoop, Sheds, Storage
Patio And Porch Features: Deck, Open, Patio, Porch

+ Land Info

Lot Description: IrregularLot, RuralLot
Lot Size Acres: 0.88
Lot Size Dimensions: 232X75
Lot Size Square Feet: 38333

+ Garage and Parking

Garage Spaces: 2
Garage Description: Detached, Driveway
Parking Features: Detached, Driveway

+ Homeowners Association

Association: No
Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees: 0

+ School Information

Elementary School District: Lyndonville
High School District: Lyndonville
Middle or Junior School District: Lyndonville
+ Display Complete School Details

Lyndonville Elementary School is a public elementary school located approximately 5.4 miles away.
Map directions

L A Webber Middle High School is a public middle and high school located approximately 5.6 miles away.
Map directions

World Life Institute Education is a private elementary, middle and high school located approximately 2.1 miles away.
Map directions

+ Other Property Info

Annual Tax Amount: 13333
Source Listing Status: Active
County: Orleans
Cross Street: Kenyonville
Directions: From Rt.104 turn north on Kenyonville road, cross the bridge, look for the signs.
Source Property Type: Residential
Area: Carlton-342400
Source Neighborhood: Carlton-342400
Parcel Number: 342400-038-001-0001-015-011
Postal City: Waterport
Property Subtype: SingleFamilyResidence
Source System Name: C2C
+ Reveal Tax History

Year	Assessments Building + Land Total	Tax
2023	$351,600 + $46,900 $398,500	$13,268
2022	$351,600 + $46,900 $398,500	$13,716
2021	$351,600 + $46,900 $398,500	$13,551
2020	$351,600 + $46,900 $398,500	$12,852
2017	$382,500 + $46,900 $429,400	$13,926
2016	$382,500 + $46,900 $429,400	$13,832
2015	$382,500 + $46,900 $429,400	$8,875
2014	$197,800 + $58,300 $256,100	$9,127
2014	$197,800 + $58,300 $256,100	$9,102
2013	$197,800 + $58,300 $256,100	$9,355
2012	$197,800 + $58,300 $256,100	$8,690
2011	$197,800 + $58,300 $256,100	$8,595
2010	$208,800 + $21,100 $229,900	$8,125
2009	$208,800 + $21,100 $229,900	$7,941
2007	$208,800 + $21,100 $229,900	$7,885

+ Reveal Property Sale History

Listed 2024-05-16
$549,900
NYStateAlliance

---

Listed 2024-02-02
$549,900
Rochester

---

Listing removed 2023-11-01
$599,999
Rochester

---

Listed 2023-03-23
$599,999
Rochester

---

Listing removed 2022-11-01
$0
Rochester

---

Price Changed 2022-07-25
$649,000
Rochester

---

Listed 2022-04-19
$695,000
Rochester

---

Sold 2005-05-16
$169,000
NYStateAlliance

---

Listed 2003-05-06
$139,900
NYStateAlliance

+ Building and Construction

Total Square Feet Living: 5965
Year Built: 1930
Building Area Source: PublicRecords
Building Area Total: 5965
Construction Materials: Block, CompositeSiding, Concrete, CopperPlumbing
Foundation Details: Block
Property Age: 94
Property Condition: Resale
Roof: Asphalt, Flat, Metal, Shingle
Levels or Stories: 3
Building Total Stories: 3
Year Built Details: Existing
Architectural Style: Farmhouse, HistoricAntique

+ Utilities

Electric: CircuitBreakers
Sewer: SepticTank
CableAvailable
WaterConnected
Water Source: Connected, Public