$350,000 Price Analysis    ♡   Cooperstown, NY 13337 4 bed 1 bath 2,200 SqFt ($159/SqFt) 8.0 acre lot. Built 1850 Listed 2021-04-08, Taxes $3,726 | ✓ USDA Eligible near Otsego, NY Restrictions may apply due to home size |
ONCE UPON A TIME and ONCE IN A LIFETIME!
* No Longer For Sale *
Your browser will attempt to redirect you to the city level in a few seconds.
Picturesque Fly Creek Setting Offering Circa 1850 Eyebrow Colonial Home, Post and Beam Barn, Stocked Pond, 8+/-Acres, Stunning Vistas with Optional 10+/- Acres. A beloved property by three proprietors since 1840, the first of record was the Cheney family, holding the property for nearly 100 years, while the home then served as an Inn along the new Turnpike, to which the location resulted from an approval by Judge William Cooper, who recognized Joseph Cheney as an enterprising individual in the community and allowed the turnpike location near his Inn.
Rumor has it Amelia Earhart once stayed at this Inn, as she gave flying lessons nearby. The third and current owner has adored this property for 75 years highlighting the kitchen with vintage Youngstown sink and cabinets and an early American Glenwood cast iron stove, adding a living room fireplace and converting the original woodshed into a family room with an antique Cottage Andes woodstove & restored barn boards, also refinishing, restoring and keeping as much of the history as possible , including wide pine flooring, doors and latches, along with an extensive barn restoration. Now waiting for the fourth holder to be put down on record and to embrace and appreciate the rich sensitive past that has adred this truly exquisite homestead with it's perfect proximity to Cooperstown. $350, 000.
Property MLS #130055 from OtsegoDelaware
Bedroom 1 Level: One
Bedroom 2 Level: One
Bedroom 3 Level: Two
Bedroom 4 Level: Two
Full Bathrooms: 1
Bathroom 1 Level: One
Electric Heat
Forced Air Heat
Oil Heating
Woodstove
Kitchen Level: One
Living Room Level: One
Pond
Storage/Out-Building
Lot Size Acres: 8.0
Lot Size Square Feet: 348480
Garage Description: Attached, Barn
Map directions Map directions Map directionsCounty: Otsego
Source Property Type: Single Family Residence
Area: 24
Source Neighborhood: 24
Source System Name: C2C
| Year | Assessments Building + Land Total | Tax |
|---|---|---|
| 2020 | $205,100 + $86,900 $292,000 | $3,726 |
| 2019 | $205,100 + $86,900 $292,000 | $3,630 |
| 2018 | $205,100 + $86,900 $292,000 | $3,598 |
| 2017 | $205,100 + $86,900 $292,000 | $3,820 |
| 2016 | $205,100 + $86,900 $292,000 | $3,624 |
| 2015 | $205,100 + $86,900 $292,000 | $3,623 |
| 2014 | $203,100 + $88,900 $292,000 | $3,015 |
$350,000
OtsegoDelaware
Listing removed 2021-06-01
$375,000
OtsegoDelaware
Listed 2021-04-08
$350,000
OtsegoDelaware
Listing removed 2020-06-01
$394,000
OtsegoDelaware
Listing removed 2020-04-28
$394,000
OtsegoDelaware
Listed 2019-12-06
$394,000
OtsegoDelaware
Year Built: 1850
Construction Materials: Frame
Property Age: 171
Structure Type: Residential
Sewer: Septic System
Water Source: Well
The property loan eligibility may be subject to additional requirements beyond geographical location including but not limited to the condition of the property. Speak with a real estate professional to find out more about the eligibility of a specific property.