Loading Data
All Active Listings Near
Shelter Island, New York in Suffolk County 
Postal Code: 11964
Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates | |
| $19,975,000 34A N Cartwright Rd | |
Listed by Stacey Cohen at Saunders & Associates | |
| $11,250,000 10 Thompson Rd | *New Construction* |
 Ⓧ USDA 34  Listed by Seth P. Madore at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island | |
| $9,950,000 55 Shore Rd | |
Listed by Tina Marika Kaasik at Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty | |
| $9,900,000 47L S Ferry Rd | *New Construction* |
 Ⓧ USDA 10 Listed by Kerry Gaynor at Voro Llc. Latest property estimate: $9,362,600 | |
| $9,750,000 8 Cobbetts Ln | *New Construction* |
 Ⓧ USDA 23 Listed by Peter M. Mccracken at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island | |
| $9,100,000 21 Harbor Ln | |
 Ⓧ USDA 32 Listed by Seth P. Madore at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island | |
| $7,500,000 23 Harbor Ln | |
 Ⓧ USDA 17 Listed by Melina Wein at M Wein Realty Inc | |
| $6,500,000 179 Ram Island Dr | |
 Ⓧ USDA 20 Listed by Rebecca Shafer at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island. Latest property estimate: $2,529,000 | |
| $5,900,000 16 Little Ram Island Dr | |
 Ⓧ USDA 5 Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates | |
| $5,750,000 82 S Midway Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 44 Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates | |
| $5,445,000 6-6A S Ram Island Dr | |
Listed by Patrick Patrick Mclaughlin at Douglas Elliman - Sag Harbor | |
| $5,250,000 115 S Ferry Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 49 Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates. Latest property estimate: $2,185,200 | |
| $4,950,000 17 Nostrand Pkwy | |
 Ⓧ USDA 20 Listed by Nicholas Brown at Sotheby's International Realty - East Hampton Brokerage | |
| $4,550,000 11 Dickerson Dr | |
Listed by Melina Wein at M Wein Realty Inc. Latest property estimate: $2,176,900 | |
| $4,350,000 7 S Cartwright Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 5 Listed by Hedgerow Exclusive Team at Hedgerow Exclusive Properties | |
| $3,995,000 47B S Ferry Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 14 Listed by Seth P. Madore at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island | |
| $3,950,000 8 Hilo Dr | *New Construction* |
 Ⓧ USDA 18 Listed by Mala Sander at The Corcoran Group - Sag Harbor | |
| $3,595,000 52 S Midway Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 3 Listed by Louise Poleshuk at Corcoran Group (Shelter Island) | |
| $3,499,000 166 Ram Island Dr | |
 Ⓧ USDA 5 Listed by Louise Poleshuk at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island | |
| $3,499,000 166 Ram Island Dr | |
 Ⓧ USDA 36 Listed by Peter Humphrey at Greenport. Latest property estimate: $2,416,200 | |
| $3,385,000 4 Gazon Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 36 Listed by Debra Von Brook Binder at Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty | |
| $3,200,000 10B Sunshine Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 38 Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates | |
| $3,100,000 5 Sea Gull Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 24 Listed by Brianna Brianna Ottati at Douglas Elliman - Sag Harbor | |
| $2,995,000 20 Margarets Dr | |
 Ⓧ USDA 23 Listed by Mary E Galle at Corcoran Westhampton Beach. Latest property estimate: $2,791,700 | |
| $2,995,000 3 Bevan Pl | |
 Ⓧ USDA 32 Listed by Peter M. Mccracken at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island | |
| $2,975,000 106 S Ferry Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 13 Listed by Theresa R. Andrew at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island | |
| $2,950,000 6 Brander Pkwy | |
 Ⓧ USDA 34 Listed by Tina Marika Kaasik at Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty. Latest property estimate: $2,811,900 | |
| $2,950,000 4 Irene Ln | |
 Ⓧ USDA 34 Listed by Regina Surerus at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island. Latest property estimate: $1,787,800 | |
| $2,795,000 7 Gazon Rd | |
Listed by Christine Beckwith at Douglas Elliman Real Estate. Latest property estimate: $2,039,000 | |
| $2,690,000 8 Crescent Way | |
 Ⓧ USDA 35 Listed by David Tenenbaum at Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons | |
| $2,495,000 45 New York Ave | *New Listing* |
 Ⓧ USDA 29 Listed by Michael Brennan at Sag Harbor. Latest property estimate: $2,305,800 | |
| $2,495,000 18 Dickerson Dr | |
Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates | |
| $2,475,000 17 Crescent Way | |
 Ⓧ USDA 25 Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates | |
| $2,375,000 40 Dinah Rock Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 26 Listed by Debra Von Brook Binder at Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty | |
| $2,250,000 74 Peconic Ave | |
 Ⓧ USDA 27 Listed by Christine Beckwith at Douglas Elliman Real Estate. Latest property estimate: $1,175,400 | |
| $2,195,000 3 Crab Creek Rd | *New Listing* |
 Ⓧ USDA 25 Listed by Louise Poleshuk at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island. Latest property estimate: $1,175,400 | |
| $2,195,000 3 Crab Creek Rd | *New Listing* |
 Ⓧ USDA 25 Listed by Peter M. Mccracken at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island. Latest property estimate: $1,757,700 | |
| $2,100,000 9 Crescent Way | |
 Ⓧ USDA 4 Listed by Jonathan Minerick at Apaus, Inc. Latest property estimate: $2,021,400 | |
| $2,050,000 8 Tims Trl | *New Construction* |
 Ⓧ USDA 44 Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates. Latest property estimate: $2,234,400 | |
| $2,050,000 27 Country Club Dr | |
 Ⓧ USDA 21 Listed by Angelo Piccozzi at Dering Harbor Real Estate Llc | |
| $1,999,999 15 W Neck Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 25 Listed by Lisa Bass at Saunders & Associates | |
| $1,999,999 15 W Neck Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 18 Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates. Latest property estimate: $1,359,100 | |
| $1,999,000 9 Behringer Ln | |
 Ⓧ USDA 25 Listed by Regina Surerus at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island. Latest property estimate: $1,634,900 | |
| $1,950,000 70 S Ferry Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 30 Listed by Gioia Gioia Dipaolo at Douglas Elliman - Sag Harbor. Latest property estimate: $1,634,900 | |
| $1,950,000 70 S Ferry Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 49 Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates. Latest property estimate: $1,581,200 | |
| $1,900,000 10 Crescent Way | |
Listed by Angelo Piccozzi at Dering Harbor Real Estate Llc | |
| $1,900,000 42 Country Club Dr | |
 Ⓧ USDA 23 Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates. Latest property estimate: $1,724,800 | |
| $1,895,000 29 Brander Pkwy | |
 Ⓧ USDA 34 Listed by Cynthia R. Barrett at Brown Harris Stevens (Bridgehampton) | |
| $1,850,000 3 Seagull Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 28 Listed by Cynthia Barrett at Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons | |
| $1,850,000 3 Seagull Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 27 Listed by Christian Fanning at Corcoran East Side. Latest property estimate: $1,670,100 | |
| $1,800,000 7 Marc St | |
 Ⓧ USDA 26 Listed by Rachel Louise Rushforth-worrell at Brown Harris Stevens (Sag Harbor). Latest property estimate: $1,670,100 | |
| $1,800,000 7 Marc St | |
 Ⓧ USDA 27 Listed by Rachel Rushforth-worrell at Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons. Latest property estimate: $1,670,100 | |
| $1,800,000 7 Marc St | |
 Ⓧ USDA 35 Listed by Debra Von Brook Binder at Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty | |
| $1,750,000 1 Deer Park Ln | |
Listed by Tina Marika Kaasik at Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty | |
| $1,695,000 16 Great Circle Dr | |
 Ⓧ USDA 22 Listed by Angelo Piccozzi at Dering Harbor Real Estate Llc. Latest property estimate: $1,083,000 | |
| $1,585,000 5 Mimosa Pl | |
 Ⓧ USDA 43 Listed by Tina Marika Kaasik at Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty. Latest property estimate: $1,549,900 | |
| $1,575,000 5 Country Club Dr | |
 Ⓧ USDA 33 Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates | |
| $1,495,000 81 N Midway Rd | |
Listed by Angelo Piccozzi at Dering Harbor Real Estate Llc | |
| $1,485,000 5 Stearns Point Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 29 Listed by Simon Harrison at Simon Harrison Real Estate | |
| $1,350,000 4 Duvall Pl | |
 Ⓧ USDA 14 Listed by Simon Harrison at Simon Harrison Real Estate | |
| $1,350,000 28 Smith St | |
 Ⓧ USDA 15 Listed by Louise Poleshuk at Corcoran Group (Shelter Island). Latest property estimate: $1,090,300 | |
| $1,295,000 27 S Ferry Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 18 Listed by Louise Poleshuk at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island. Latest property estimate: $1,090,300 | |
| $1,295,000 27 S Ferry Rd | |
Listed by Angelo Piccozzi at Dering Harbor Real Estate Llc | |
| $1,285,000 2 Cozy Ln | |
 Ⓧ USDA 13 Listed by Regina Surerus at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island | |
| $1,250,000 65 N Midway Rd | |
Listed by Debra Von Brook Binder at Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty. Latest property estimate: $1,165,800 | |
| $1,200,000 36 Rocky Point Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 6 Listed by Regina Surerus at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island | |
| $1,100,000 6 Dering Woods Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 6 Listed by Annmarie Seddio at ATLAS SALES REALTY LLC | |
| $1,100,000 2 Dering Woods Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 10 Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates | |
| $999,000 1 Dering Woods Rd | |
 Ⓧ USDA 18 Listed by Donald Killinger at Myrta Echevarria Ltd | |
| $995,000 3 Lakeview Dr | |
 Ⓧ USDA 9 Listed by Penelope Moore at Saunders & Associates | |
| $795,000 6 Great Circle Dr | *New Listing* |
 👍 USDA Loan 6 Listed by Scott Bennett at Douglas Elliman Real Estate | |
| $750,000 3 S Cartwright Rd | *New Listing* |
 👍 USDA Loan 8 ♡ Listed by Christopher Read at READ CHRISTOPHER M | |
| $645,000 56A N Menantic Rd | |
 👍 USDA Loan 2 Listed by Theresa R. Andrew at The Corcoran Group - Shelter Island | |
| $625,000 8 Pennys Path | |
 👍 USDA Loan 5 ♡ Listed by Melina Wein at M Wein Realty Inc | |
| $530,000 13 Winthrop Rd Unit 19 | |
View more properties near Shelter Island